« More on oral assessments | Main | Coan on the Court »
Wednesday, January 11, 2023
The Trustworthiness of American Lawyers (Part II)
The following post comes from Michael Ariens (St. Mary's), the second in a series about his new book, The Lawyer's Conscience A History of American Lawyer Ethics (University of Kansas Press).
Perhaps the most eventful experience in David Hoffman’s life occurred when he was nearly lynched for actions related to his opposition to the War of 1812. Hoffman and other Federalists battled supporters of the war, resulting first in the deaths of several supporters, and, after the arrest and jailing of Hoffman’s compatriots, the murder of one of those jailed. Hoffman would have been hanged “but for the providential interference of a stranger, who satisfied the murderers that they had got hold of the wrong man.”
Five years later, Hoffman’s A Course of Legal Study was published, praised by Justice Joseph Story and others. It was intended to serve those interested in learning law; soon after its publication Hoffman began lecturing interested law students in Maryland. The 1817 edition included a list of readings concerning how lawyers should act. In 1836, the second edition of A Course of Legal Study was published. Over twice the length of the original, the second edition included an introductory essay on the standards of behavior, followed by fifty Rules in Regard to Professional Deportment. Hoffman’s essay and rules were premised on the lawyer’s duty to act honorably. Too often lawyers exercised power in search of wealth and fame. Neither demonstrated a lawyer was honorable, which was the true measure of professional success. Only when lawyers sought honor did they elevate both themselves and the legal profession. His introductory essay used “honor,” “honorable,” and “honorably” thirteen times. Hoffman’s Rules were also premised on the idea of honor, using it or its variants eleven times.
Hoffman’s second edition was poorly received, selling poorly and reviewed rarely. In 1846, Hoffman’s Hints on the Professional Deportment of Lawyers was published. Hints reprinted in one book all of Hoffman’s writings on lawyer ethics. Hints wasn’t received at all; neither the remaining existing legal publications nor literary magazines reviewed it. And it appears it sold worse than the second edition (which was also reprinted in 1846). Hoffman moved to England in 1847. He returned to the United States in 1854, the year in which he died.
Hoffman embraced aristocracy; to be called an aristocrat was a term of honor. He excoriated Jacksonian democracy as “jacobinical” mob rule. But he was an aristocrat living in a democratic age. This made his Rules both incisive and out-of-date. For example, Hoffman condemned the lawyer who purchased the client’s interest in the case, for that purchase occurred only after the lawyer knew the strength of the case. This was a conflict of interest. Hoffman contrasted such cases with a lawyer’s taking a case on a contingent fee. That was permissible, for it permitted poor clients to obtain representation when otherwise impossible. Further, an honorable lawyer provided the same diligence to every client, no matter how large or small the matter. And an honorable lawyer returned a client’s money before any need to request it. An honorable lawyer simply did not take advantage of one’s clients.
But Hoffman’s emphasis on honor also led him to promote ethics rules lawyers had already discarded. Hoffman urged lawyers not to plead either the statute of limitations or the defense of infancy against an honest demand. Hoffman was well aware that both defenses were permitted by law in Maryland. But he reserved to the lawyer the position as “sole judge … of the occasions proper for their use.” To aid a “guilty” client to evade responsibility by use of such defenses was to diminish the honor of lawyers. Lawyers ignored Hoffman’s pleas to maintain their honor, as other writers urged a slightly different path.
One of those writers was Timothy Walker. In an 1839 speech to law graduates, Walker emphasized conscience rather than honor. Though Walker, like Hoffman, urged lawyers to avoid dishonorable means when practicing law, Walker interpreted honor to mean a lawyer should practice law with integrity and dignity. Walker’s intention was to permit lawyers to represent a client with a “bad cause,” which Hoffman rejected. If the lawyer could keep his conscience in representing the bad cause, the lawyer was acting consonant with moral principles: “[A] lawyer is not accountable for the moral character of the cause he prosecutes, but only for the manner in which he conducts it.” Walker gave three reasons why a lawyer should take “doubtful” cases: first, prejudging a case might lead the lawyer to error; second, the lawyer did not keep the client’s conscience; and third, “Every man … has a right to have his case fairly presented before the court.”
The concept of lawyerly honor faded slowly, as internal conscience began to replace external honor as the standard for assessing lawyer behavior. By the early twentieth century, newly-created bar associations, including the American Bar Association (1878), resolved to create written rules of professional conduct. Part III suggests several reasons why American lawyers, particularly elite lawyers, considered it necessary to establish such rules.
Posted by Howard Wasserman on January 11, 2023 at 09:31 AM in Books, Law and Politics | Permalink
Comments
informative thank you
Posted by: Jayabal | Jan 1, 2024 8:08:35 PM
Thanks for sharing with us. Explore the premier choice for ISO 13485 lead auditor training, ensuring a thorough and impactful learning journey.
Posted by: punyam | Dec 29, 2023 6:06:20 AM
Drift Hunters: Unleash the Drift Legend Within!
Posted by: Drift Hunters | Dec 19, 2023 9:52:20 PM
blog is very nice...
New product development has become increasingly difficult for many companies in today’s fast-paced environment. To capture the customer’s attention, the business must use powerful techniques and methods.sap sd online cource in hyderabad
Posted by: mylearnnest | Dec 17, 2023 7:01:56 AM
very nice blog..
Digital marketing is among the trending courses most students and working professionals want to learn, and the reason is enormous demand and a bright future ahead.digital marketing kukatpally
Posted by: codingpromaster | Dec 17, 2023 6:55:12 AM
your post is very nice...
Appian is a low coding platform BPM (Business Process Management) tool that allows users and organizations to build the app by simple drag-and-drop options and helps automate complex business processes efficiently.
Posted by: codingpromaster | Dec 12, 2023 1:08:23 AM
Elevate your skills and knowledge with our industry-leading courses. Visit our website for a transformative learning experience. Your journey to mastery begins here
GST Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: swapna | Dec 9, 2023 3:03:12 AM
Elevate your skills and knowledge with our industry-leading courses. Visit our website for a transformative learning experience. Your journey to mastery begins here
GST Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: swapna | Dec 9, 2023 3:03:12 AM
Accounting Mastery is an education hub specializing in advanced accounting training, offering courses and resources for individuals to excel in the field.
Advanced Excel Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: maanavi | Dec 8, 2023 3:10:35 AM
A Business Accounting and Taxation course is designed to provide individuals with a comprehensive understanding of financial accounting principles and taxation practices within the context of business operations. This type of course is particularly relevant for those pursuing careers in finance, accounting, or entrepreneurship.
For further details log in : Business Accounting and Taxation Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: Poorna | Dec 7, 2023 11:24:14 AM
Lectortmo se destaca como una de las plataformas online más populares para disfrutar de mangas en línea, especialmente en países de habla hispana.
Posted by: online | Dec 7, 2023 6:21:38 AM
Accounting mastery is the culmination of acquiring a deep understanding and proficiency in the principles, practices, and methodologies of accounting. It goes beyond the basic knowledge of debits and credits, financial statements, and bookkeeping, delving into a comprehensive grasp of the intricate facets of financial management.
Business Accounting and Taxation Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: Neha | Dec 6, 2023 10:35:42 AM
nice blog post
thank you for sharing with us.
GCP Interview Questions And Answers
Posted by: asritha | Dec 6, 2023 8:23:56 AM
Accounting mastery is the culmination of acquiring a deep understanding and proficiency in the principles, practices, and methodologies of accounting. It goes beyond the basic knowledge of debits and credits, financial statements, and bookkeeping, delving into a comprehensive grasp of the intricate facets of financial management.
Business Accounting and Taxation Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: Ramya | Dec 5, 2023 11:22:31 AM
Brolly Arts is a dynamic and diverse institution that stands at the forefront of holistic education, offering a range of courses that cater to individuals seeking creative expression and physical well-being. With a commitment to nurturing talent and fostering a sense of community, Brolly Arts has carved a niche for itself by providing courses in guitar, dance, arts, and yoga.Guitar Classes In Hyderabad
Posted by: Vani | Dec 5, 2023 9:05:36 AM
"Thank you for this informative article. I learned a lot."
sailpoint certification Training
Posted by: SailPoint training in Hyderabad | Nov 25, 2023 7:07:03 AM
Thank you , it helps me alot for my research
Front End Developer Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: lamp | Oct 18, 2023 3:27:19 AM
Thank you , it helps me alot for my research
Front End Developer Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: lamp | Oct 18, 2023 3:26:23 AM
Thanks you your valuable thoughts.
Posted by: GCP MASTERS | Oct 9, 2023 3:37:55 AM
Thanks for sharing with us.
Posted by: GCP MASTERS | Oct 9, 2023 3:37:22 AM
thanks for valuble information
nice article
mulesoft training
Posted by: mulemasters training | Oct 8, 2023 12:53:55 AM
thanks for valuable information
mulesoft training
Posted by: mulemasters training | Oct 5, 2023 1:13:28 PM
nice information
Python Course in Hyderabad
Posted by: sb | Sep 27, 2023 4:51:19 AM
nice article
thank you for provieding such useful information Angular training in Hyderabad
Posted by: lamp | Aug 27, 2023 10:48:05 AM
Your post has those facts which are not accessible from anywhere else. It’s my humble request to u please keep writing such remarkable articles
thanks for shareing
Digital Marketing Course In Hyderabad
Posted by: nani | Aug 17, 2023 12:39:56 AM
Great post!
Thanks for sharing with us 🙂
Dental Clinic in Manikonda
Posted by: nani | Aug 16, 2023 10:53:24 AM
Nicely written and great info about books
Posted by: sclintech soft | Aug 6, 2023 2:54:41 PM
Nice Article!
Thanks for sharing with us 🙂
Azure Devops Interview Questions
Azure Data Factory Interview Questions
Azure Admin Interview Questions
Posted by: azuretrainings.in | May 5, 2023 9:07:21 AM
Thank you for sharing infomationPure Turmeric Powder
Posted by: natures box | May 3, 2023 2:06:53 AM
"Wow, what a fantastic article! I was thoroughly impressed by your writing style, the depth of research, and the insights you shared. your article truly added value to my understanding of the topic. I will definitely be recommending it to others. Keep up the great work!"
Posted by: chandu | Mar 17, 2023 6:19:15 AM
I found your article very informative.
Digital marketing course in Guwahati!
Posted by: NABA | Jan 30, 2023 1:05:29 PM
I found your article very informative.
Digital marketing course in Guwahati!
Posted by: NABA | Jan 30, 2023 1:05:29 PM
Your content is always top-notch, keep it up!
Digital marketing course in Hyderabad!
Posted by: NABA | Jan 30, 2023 1:04:45 PM
In My Oppinion Justice is Everyone,s Right. Those people who raise there voices in seek of justice are those who know justice is important. These Types Of blogs in which They provide people awareness about how to get thier rights are my faviourite blogs. I am Now Giving You Hope About Getting right In South Carolina Must Visit : Car Accident Lawyer Greenville Sc
Posted by: Luca Mike | Jan 25, 2023 7:39:34 AM
In My Oppinion Justice is Everyone,s Right. Those people who raise there voices in seek of justice are those who know justice is important. These Types Of blogs in which They provide people awareness about how to get thier rights are my faviourite blogs. I am Now Giving You Hope About Getting right In South Carolina Must Visit : Car Accident Lawyer Greenville Sc
Posted by: Luca Mike | Jan 25, 2023 7:39:13 AM
"Great post! I really enjoyed reading it and found it informative.
BEST DIGITAL MARKETING COURSE IN GUWAHATI!
Posted by: NABA | Jan 21, 2023 12:44:00 AM
pgslot ยอดเยี่ยมเกมออนไลน์ สล็อตบนโทรศัพท์เคลื่อนที่ เป็บเว็บเกมออนไลน์ที่อยากจะแนะนำที่สุดต้อง pgslot-th.com เกมแบบใหม่ ไม่มีเบื่อ ไม่ซ้ำๆซากๆ ในแบบการเล่นเดิมๆอีกต่อไปๆ
Posted by: ไม่มีเบื่อ ไม่ซ้ำ | Jan 14, 2023 6:05:47 AM
Watch All Seasons Episodes Of Colors Hindi TV Serial Pyar Ke Saat Vachan Dharam Patni> Online. DharamPatni Watch Online Desi Serial Hindi Drama By Voot,
Posted by: dharam patni serial | Jan 12, 2023 2:59:29 AM
The comments to this entry are closed.