« Limiting rules in football | Main | A teaching experiment »

Monday, January 06, 2020

AJC's @JewishandProud Day (Updated)

AJC has designated today--Monday, January 6--as #JewishandProud Day, with a campaign urging people to "wear your Jewishness publicly" and to post pictures with your Jewishness and the slogan below on social media.

Action Alert_#JewishProud_v2

One somewhat related, if delayed point: The story from last week about the dismissal of the entire class of cadets at West Virginia's corrections academy after they were photographed giving a Nazi salute beneath a sign reading "Hail, Byrd," in reference to instructor Karrie Byrd. According to reports, Byrd got into trouble (and is no longer employed by the state) because her statement to investigators that she was "not familiar with the 'historical or racial implications of the gesture' and that it was 'simply a greeting,'" was contradicted by testimony that Byrd encouraged the gesture and told a secretary that she is "a hard-ass like Hitler." Which suggests that had her defense not been contradicted by evidence that reveled in the salute, she might have kept her job--had it been true that she did not know the history or racism at issue, she would not have been fired.

Which brings me to what I have been thinking: Can we please agree that anyone who is not familiar with the historical and racial implications of the Nazi salute and "Heil Hitler" is too fucking stupid to hold any position of public trust?

Update I: A colleague stumbled across this 2004 RBG speech at the U.S. Holocaust Memorial, talking about how the Shoah played in Hungary and about her Jewish experience. Appropriate for the day.

Update II: I have closed comments, having spent the better part of today deleting updwards of 30 anonymous comments saying that the author hated me and thought I was vermin because I am anti-gun. Also comparing Justice Steven's Heller dissent to Holocaust denial. Not sure how this post could become about guns (or what I have ever written indicating I am anti-gun), but it got out of hand in a hurry.

Posted by Howard Wasserman on January 6, 2020 at 09:31 AM in Howard Wasserman | Permalink


Understanding the historical and racial implications would seem to suggest that there is something specially evil or offensive about Hitler and the Nazi regime.

But the amount of time people who hold positions of public trust have compared their political opponents to Hitler and the Nazis in the last four years suggests the opposite.

Otherwise, we'd be much more careful about who we accused of being a Hitler or a Nazi.

Posted by: thegreatdisappointment | Jan 6, 2020 7:04:37 PM

Byrd was obviously lying, but the mythical Roman salute, accompanied by "Hail Caesar," is pretty similar to the Nazi salute, as can be seen on the Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_salute

Posted by: Steven Lubet | Jan 6, 2020 11:12:39 AM

The comments to this entry are closed.