« Fixing Direct Democracy | Main | Justice Palmer's apology to Susette Kelo versus Justice Kennedy's Kelo concurrence: What's the problem that the "public use" doctrine is trying to solve? »

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

What is the Point of Law School Grading Curves if They're Not (More) Fixed?

The way I see it, there are basically 2 points to having grading curves in law school:

(1) We want a forced distribution of grades so that relevant players can distinguish among students in the top, middle, and bottom of the class (e.g., schools can decide which students make which journals and employers can decide which students get which jobs); and

(2) We can ensure that there is fairness across sections. If students in Section A have a torts professor who has a median GPA of 2.8 every semester and students in Section B have a torts professor who has a median GPA of 3.2 every semester, it is easy to see how unfairness results.

Of course, we may (and many do) question under (1) how much of a role a student's GPA/class rank should play in journal/hiring/other decisions. And we may question under (2) whether a grading curve does produce fairness. What if students in Section A just happened to be "better" than students in Section B, whether intentionally or accidentally?

But here's the thing under (2): From what I've seen, most law school grading curves aren't like admission fees at museums, i.e., they're not fixed. Instead, they're (often extremely) variable. They're like suggested donations at museums. One patron could give the suggested donation of $5. Another patron could give nothing. And a third patron could give $10. This being the case, what is their point?

For example, here is the grading curve for required courses at Seton Hall University Law School (picked at random and at least somewhat similar to curves at many other law schools):

A+ and A       15-25% (see below)

A- and B+      minimum 15% (see below)

B                       minimum 15% (see below)

B- and C+       10-25%

C and C-         10-25%

D+, D and F  5-15%

Grades in the first two categories of the foregoing grade distribution schemes should not exceed 50% of the overall class.

Grades in the first three categories of the foregoing grade distribution schemes should not exceed 70% of the overall class.

So, in Section A of Torts (100 students), Professor A could give:

5 A+s and 20 As (25%)

20 A-s and 5 B+s (25%/50% total)

20 Bs (20%/70% total)

10 B-s and 5 C+s (15%/85% total)

10 Cs (10%/95% total)

5 D+s (5%/100% total)

Meanwhile, in Section B of torts (100 students), Professor B could give:

2 A+s and 13 As (15%)

3 A-s and 12 B+s (15%/30% total)

15 Bs (15%/45% total)

5 B-s and 10 C+s (15%/60% total)

10 Cs and 15 C-s (25%/85% total)

2 D+s, 5 Ds, and 5 Fs (15%/100% total)

Now, I don't need to crunch the numbers to tell you that students in Section B are getting the short end of the stick. And maybe it is justified. Maybe, as I noted above, the students in Section A are "better" than the students in Section B. And maybe that's the point of a flexible curve. If I have a terrific set of students in a given semester, I might give grades like Professor A above. If, during another semester, I have a collection of Sweathogs, I might give grades like Professor B above. Most semesters, my grades will fall somewhere in between these 2 extremes. And while a flexible curve gives me some flexibility, it still gives me boundaries so that my grades aren't that different from the grades of a professor teaching a different section of the same course.

In an ideal world, this all makes sense. But does it make sense in the real world? From talking to colleagues, I get the general sense that the answer is "no" because I think that a course's curve tells us more about the professor than her students. I know some professors who consistently award grades at the bottom of the curve and would give lower grades if they could. Conversely, I know some professors who award grades at the top of the curve and would give higher grades if they could. In other words, some professors are "hard" graders and other professors are "easy" graders, and a student in a section with a 3.2 median is "lucky" while a student in a section with a 2.8 median is "unlucky."

But let's say that I'm wrong. Let's say that most professors modulate their curves based upon the performance of each collection of students in each class. It is still easy to imagine problems. In a torts class in fall 2011, the median on the exam is 72 in both Sections A and B. Professor A and B each create curves where the median GPA is 3.0. In the fall of 2012, the median on the exam is 76 in both Sections A and B. Professor A concludes that this was an exceptionally bright class and awards a median GPA of 3.2. Professor B concludes that this was an exceptionally easy exam and awards a median GPA of 3.0. Both professors could be correct, but they both could easily be incorrect. Maybe the students in Section B were exceptionally bright and the exam in Section A was exceptionally easy.

And there's no easy way (as I see it) for Professor A and Professor B to compare notes to ensure consistent results. First, it is pretty tough (at least for me) to determine the difficulty of a test (especially) for a class I didn't teach. I'm Professor A. A good deal of Professor B's exam deals with the attractive nuisance doctrine. Is the exam easy or difficult? I don't know. How much time did Professor B spend on the doctrine? What cases did she use? How good was the class discussion when the doctrine was covered? Second, it is difficult to judge the quality of other professors (or ourselves). Is Professor B so adept at the Socratic Method that she would make Socrates himself blush? Or is Professor B teaching contributory negligence as the majority rule?

My point in all of this is to say that it is very difficult for a professor to determine whether his section is especially bright (or dim) or whether this characteristic is shared by the class of 201# as a whole. And trying to make assumptions based upon reading the exams and exam answers from other sections isn't likely to be helpful.

So, what's my overall point? I think it is that law school curves should be less flexible.  I cited to Seton Hall's curve above, and you can see the disparity that can result between two sections under the curve. The same goes at many other law schools. For instance, at Chicago-Kent, 20% of students in Section A might get As or A-s while in Section B that percentage might be 5%. Are these and many other curves too loose, or are there good reasons for keeping law school curves as flexible as they are at many (most?) law schools? Are you an "easy" or a "tough" grader or do you significantly change your curve from semester to semester? 

-Colin Miller

Posted by Evidence ProfBlogger on September 21, 2011 at 04:09 PM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c6a7953ef01543599fd46970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What is the Point of Law School Grading Curves if They're Not (More) Fixed?:

Comments

Technical support for the configuration of the Netgear extender, which also improves the network speed. The New Extender Setup Instructions will be issued on the Netgear Extender Setup Page. Visit the homepage for settings.

Posted by: NETGEAR AC1200 SETUP | Mar 6, 2021 1:35:40 AM

This website is only a guide for users to understand the process to Download, Install and Activate Norton Products, we do not have any affiliations from Norton and any other company related to Antivirus. Norton is considered one of the most effective antivirus software among Mac and Windows users. Norton Setup can help you install the security program on your computer effortlessly, and you can get it from Norton Setup. This antivirus is a full-fledged PC protection suite, so once you have installed it on your device, you won't need the default security program that comes with all Windows 10 computers.

Posted by: Norton.com/setup | Mar 5, 2021 2:14:04 PM

We brought the best deal for you; book now your used car spare parts online at carpartjunction.com. Now get the defective parts of your car at the lowest price.

Posted by: Mickel Richard | Mar 4, 2021 5:32:44 AM

Buy online Rugby Headgear at best price range only from NZ Cricket Store with World Wide shipping services.

Posted by: NZ Cricket | Mar 4, 2021 12:32:34 AM

For those who are facing any sort of issue or want to personally talk to the representatives, head to the Delta Airlines Office In Kathmandu. From helping you out with booking your flight to managing your flight and everything in between

Posted by: Delta Airlines Office in Kathmandu | Mar 3, 2021 12:56:53 AM

Such Good Article... Thanks for posting !!!

Posted by: ShwetaBasu | Mar 1, 2021 9:35:27 AM

Thanks for sharing this information. https://www.zoomvirtualoffice.com/

Posted by: Virtual Office | Feb 27, 2021 1:13:17 AM

Leptoconnect reviews @ https://www.laweekly.com/leptoconnect-reviews-2021-official-upto-80-off-with-real-customer-reviews/
Resurge reviews @ https://www.laweekly.com/resurge-review-2021-update-upto-80-off-on-resurge-pills-supplement/
Proven Supplement @ https://www.laweekly.com/proven-supplement-reviews-2021-update-upto-80-off-on-proven-weight-loss-pills/

Posted by: organifi | Feb 25, 2021 6:06:27 AM

Good Article ...

Posted by: IsaJain.com | Feb 25, 2021 6:02:42 AM

This website is only a guide for users to understand the process to Download, Install and Activate Webroot Products, We do not have any affiliations from Webroot and any other company related to Antivirus. Do you wish to browse the web without worrying about any cyber threats? Undoubtedly, technology is a powerful thing that has made everything possible and easy for us. But, on the other hand, it can be harmful as well if we don’t take the precautions to keep our devices and their data safe. So, what can one do to protect their devices and data from all cyber threats? Well, the answer is obvious.

Posted by: webroot login | Feb 24, 2021 9:14:46 AM

This website is only a guide for users to understand the process to Download, Install and Activate Microsoft Office 365 Products, We do not have any affiliations from Microsoft and any other company related to softwares. In the current scenario, all the corporations and firms are in the race of acquiring the global market. That's why universally adopted applications like MS Office are omnipresent. Maybe it is the extensive document compatibility or comprehensive use of Office that makes it a must in office, school, and college. The office has features like Spell Checker, Thesaurus, and OneDrive that satisfies the myriad necessities of every customer.

Posted by: office.com/setup | Feb 22, 2021 3:46:08 PM

This website is only a guide for users to understand the process to Download, Install and Activate McAfee Products like Mcafee Total Protection, McAfee Livesafe, we do not have any affiliations from McAfee.com/activate and any other company related to Antivirus. Day by day, it's getting harder to keep a computer protected from ongoing cyber-attacks, but meanwhile, McAfee is making its security programs even smarter. There is no virus or computer algorithm that can beat McAfee. Once you have installed McAfee on your device, you can forget about viruses, spyware, ransomware, and other computer threats.

Posted by: mcafee.com/activate | Feb 22, 2021 9:14:26 AM

Delta Airlines is widely famous so as to supply amazing facilities and repair with regards flight service instantly. Contact our Delta airlines customer care number.

https://www.xpressreservation.com/delta-airlines-customer-service-phone-number/

Posted by: Mickel John | Feb 22, 2021 6:08:57 AM

Great post!

Posted by: NETGEAR EX6120 SETUP | Feb 20, 2021 3:36:47 AM

This website is only a guide for users to understand the process to Download, Install and Activate McAfee Products like Mcafee Total Protection, McAfee Livesafe, we do not have any affiliations from McAfee.com/activate and any other company related to Antivirus.Despite the fact that McAfee is available to download and install on the website, some users still consider installing and activating McAfee difficult due to being less experienced in using technology. You should not worry if you are unable to install it on your device since we have got you covered on this page.

Posted by: mcafee.com/activate | Feb 19, 2021 12:57:24 PM

It is for those students and families who require specific classic Microsoft Office apps to create an ultimate work result.
Office.com/setup Home Student 2019

Posted by: Max Turner | Feb 18, 2021 2:33:05 AM

This is a list of food verification companies that are said to be the safest place when judging whether the Mozalive is safe .

Posted by: muazlive | Feb 18, 2021 2:26:36 AM

Ap.Setup is a web page where you can configure your Wifi extender of any brand pretty easily within few minutes. If you wish to improvise the extender's wireless setting, you can do the same in the dashboard available through Ap.Setup

Posted by: comfast extender setup | Feb 17, 2021 4:25:26 AM


To begin setup Office home and student 2019, office account and office product key both are required. Users need to activate the office product key online with Microsoft Account at URL Office.com/setup. Keep remember the details of your Microsoft account so that you can download, install or reinstall office product later on.
Office.com/setup

Posted by: Office.com/setup | Feb 16, 2021 11:57:22 PM


To Setup office home and student 2019, user should have Office product key that need to be activate with Microsoft Account online at URL Office.com/setup. To activate the product key, user should have a Microsoft account. Do remember the MS Office account details so that you can user is later for reinstallation of your office product.
Office.com/setup

Posted by: Office.com/setup | Feb 16, 2021 11:56:40 PM

Shahwalia Associates is a firm with Architects in Delhi. Our highly experienced designers understand all your needs and provide you with the best solutions in your budget. We are top Ranked Interior Designer Firm in Noida.

Posted by: Mahira sharma | Feb 16, 2021 8:37:25 PM

if the user wants to access the wifi connection into another room of the location so Netgear EX7700 Setup is the best. We provide 24/7 technical support  and the users are welcome to take help from us for more info: https://www.setupmywifiextnet.us/netgear-ex7700-setup/

Posted by: Netgear EX7700 Setup | Feb 15, 2021 6:42:36 AM

This website is only a guide for users to understand the process to Download, Install and Activate Webroot Products, We do not have any affiliations from Webroot and any other company related to Antivirus.It's the world of high-speed internet and smart digital devices. These devices play a crucial role in everyone's life, but there are several disadvantages too. Electronic gadgets, especially computers, smartphones, and laptops, are more vulnerable to cybercriminals and thefts than other devices because most of the tasks are based on the internet to ease our daily work

Posted by: Webroot.com/safe | Feb 11, 2021 2:01:32 PM

McAfee is available for users with bundles of specs and features capable of scanning and removing viruses, Trojans, Malware, etc. The existence of these harmful viruses may damage the system internally, including important files and discs. In order to avoid the prevailing threats from these harmful elements, robust antivirus software is a must-have.

Posted by: McAfee.com/activate | Activate your Subscription - McAfee Activation | Feb 11, 2021 9:37:59 AM

Look for the complete guide at canon site and learn to get started to Canon inkjet setup. Find the best and easy methods and set up Canon printer hardware . [

Posted by: ij.start canon | Feb 11, 2021 7:06:45 AM

We started in 1996 as a problem-solving engineering business. This engineering mindset is ingrained into everything we do, whether you’re using one of our ground-breaking payload products or you have a Schlam Superstar working on your equipment.

Today, we’ve grown to become one of Western Australia’s largest family-owned mining services companies and you’ll find our products and maintenance people at work across mines on six continents.

With an ambition to be at every mine in the world, we’re still working to become the business we want to be.

Visit: https://schlam.com

Posted by: Schlam | Feb 10, 2021 10:45:57 PM

Aussie Mart is poised to be Australia's largest and most marketed multi-vendor marketplace allowing Australian businesses to list, sell, and promote their products free of charge.
With direct access to millions of Australians each week, it's a no-brainer!

Visit: https://www.aussiemart.com.au/

Posted by: AussieMart | Feb 10, 2021 10:41:16 PM

Over the years, we have worked hands-on to build a few thriving companies of our own in Training, Construction and Financial Services.

We boost your sales success, attract
engaged prospects, and delight your
customers to future-proof your business,
while you focus on what you do best.

https://fileroom.com/content-strategy

https://fileroom.com/document-design

https://fileroom.com/video-production-agency

Posted by: Fileroom | Feb 10, 2021 10:36:37 PM

NEINSTEIN PERSONAL INJURY LAWYERS YOUR RECOVERY STARTS HERE.

Our committed and compassionate team will do everything necessary to help you and your family during these challenging times with no upfront fees.

Useful Links:

https://neinstein.com/

https://neinstein.com/areas-of-expertise/atv-accident-lawyer/

https://neinstein.com/‎location/brampton-personal-injury-lawyer/‎

https://neinstein.com/areas-of-expertise/motorcycle-accident-lawyers/

Posted by: Neinstein | Feb 10, 2021 10:33:48 PM

Buy online Hockey Shin Guards at best price range only from NZ Cricket Store with World Wide shipping services.

Posted by: jamescooper | Feb 10, 2021 5:49:36 AM

Smart bloggers see opportunities where others do not.

Posted by: WEBROOT LOGIN | Feb 9, 2021 2:35:00 PM

Microsoft Office, widely known as "MS Office," is a suite of various productivity apps that play a significant role in office-related tasks. Several important tasks are nowadays performed with the help of this excellent program. Excel, Word, and PowerPoint are integral parts of Office and prove a lot helpful in office-related tasks. Whether you want to create documents with proper formatting or want to create an effective presentation for an official meeting, MS Office is a one-stop solution for all such tasks.

Posted by: Office.com/signin | Feb 9, 2021 1:43:56 PM

Airlines Reservation Phone Number - Call 24*7 customer care number (888-854-1953) | Flight Offers,deals,booking,cancellation,refund,changes,exchange,upgrade,reschedule

Posted by: Sophia Pual | Feb 9, 2021 6:09:18 AM

Thanks For Sharing this Information! For Asus router-related technical help visit here. https://routterasus.com/

Posted by: thornton son | Feb 9, 2021 3:42:43 AM

This website is only a guide for users to understand the process to Download, Install and Activate Webroot Products, We do not have any affiliations from Webroot and any other company related to Antivirus.Antivirus is essential software that helps in removing internet viruses and threats. But how many people use them? Internet security is a sizable concern in the 21st century. But people still choose to ignore the power of hackers and what they can do with the technology they had. It’s important to update yourself about internet security from time-to-time.

Posted by: Webroot Login | Feb 8, 2021 12:52:26 PM

Thank you so much for sharing

Posted by: ap.setup | Feb 8, 2021 6:00:39 AM

Experience is one of the most relevant thing you ever see and this is totally exp

Posted by: Tejar Pk | Feb 8, 2021 1:00:57 AM

agencia de wordpress

Posted by: agencia de wordpress | Feb 6, 2021 1:12:12 PM

agencia de SEO

Posted by: agencia de SEO | Feb 6, 2021 1:11:55 PM

agencias de marketing digital

Posted by: agencias de marketing digital | Feb 6, 2021 1:11:46 PM

agencia de marketing digital em São Paulo SP, desenvolvemos todo marketing digital para sua empresa, SEO, Links Patrocinados, Mídias

Posted by: agencia de marketing digital em São Paulo SP, desenvolvemos todo marketing digital para sua empresa, SEO, Links Patrocinados, Mídias | Feb 6, 2021 1:11:20 PM

agencia criação de sites

Posted by: agencia criação de sites | Feb 6, 2021 1:10:53 PM

tratamento dependencia quimica

Posted by: tratamento dependencia quimica | Feb 6, 2021 1:10:42 PM

clinica de internação involuntaria, clinicas de internação involuntaria, clinica de tratamento involuntario, clinicas de tratamento involuntario

Posted by: clinica de internação involuntaria, clinicas de internação involuntaria, clinica de tratamento involuntario, clinicas de tratamento involuntario | Feb 6, 2021 1:10:24 PM

tratamento alcoólatras

Posted by: tratamento alcoólatras | Feb 6, 2021 1:10:09 PM

tratamento alcoolismo

Posted by: tratamento alcoolismo | Feb 6, 2021 1:09:50 PM

tratamento dependencia quimica

Posted by: tratamento dependencia quimica | Feb 6, 2021 1:09:41 PM

clínica de recuperação masculina

Posted by: clínica de recuperação masculina | Feb 6, 2021 1:09:30 PM

clínica de reabilitação feminina

Posted by: clínica de reabilitação feminina | Feb 6, 2021 1:09:09 PM

clinica para dependentes quimicos

Posted by: clinica para dependentes quimicos | Feb 6, 2021 1:09:02 PM

clinica para drogados

Posted by: clinica para drogados | Feb 6, 2021 1:08:55 PM

clinica de reabilitação para dependentes quimicos

Posted by: clinica de reabilitação para dependentes quimicos | Feb 6, 2021 1:08:47 PM

clinica de reabilitação

Posted by: clinica de reabilitação | Feb 6, 2021 1:08:40 PM

clinica de recuperação

Posted by: clinica de recuperação | Feb 6, 2021 1:08:33 PM

tratamento dependencia quimica

Posted by: tratamento dependencia quimica | Feb 6, 2021 1:03:18 PM

clinica de recuperação

Posted by: clinica de recuperação | Feb 6, 2021 12:59:33 PM

agencia de marketing digital em São Paulo SP, desenvolvemos todo marketing digital para sua empresa, SEO, Links Patrocinados, Mídias

Posted by: agencia de marketing digital em São Paulo SP, desenvolvemos todo marketing digital para sua empresa, SEO, Links Patrocinados, Mídias | Feb 6, 2021 12:58:17 PM

Your content is very nice, thank you very much about it. I am waiting for the continuation of your posts.

Posted by: login bitdefender central | Feb 6, 2021 7:41:29 AM

for more information Wi-Fi Range extender system visit: http://www.setupampedwirelessextender.com/

Posted by: setup.ampedwireless | Feb 6, 2021 12:45:28 AM

Canon printers are user friendly and easy to install and set up.

Posted by: https ij start canon | Feb 5, 2021 4:57:57 AM

Post a comment