« Fixing Direct Democracy | Main | Justice Palmer's apology to Susette Kelo versus Justice Kennedy's Kelo concurrence: What's the problem that the "public use" doctrine is trying to solve? »

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

What is the Point of Law School Grading Curves if They're Not (More) Fixed?

The way I see it, there are basically 2 points to having grading curves in law school:

(1) We want a forced distribution of grades so that relevant players can distinguish among students in the top, middle, and bottom of the class (e.g., schools can decide which students make which journals and employers can decide which students get which jobs); and

(2) We can ensure that there is fairness across sections. If students in Section A have a torts professor who has a median GPA of 2.8 every semester and students in Section B have a torts professor who has a median GPA of 3.2 every semester, it is easy to see how unfairness results.

Of course, we may (and many do) question under (1) how much of a role a student's GPA/class rank should play in journal/hiring/other decisions. And we may question under (2) whether a grading curve does produce fairness. What if students in Section A just happened to be "better" than students in Section B, whether intentionally or accidentally?

But here's the thing under (2): From what I've seen, most law school grading curves aren't like admission fees at museums, i.e., they're not fixed. Instead, they're (often extremely) variable. They're like suggested donations at museums. One patron could give the suggested donation of $5. Another patron could give nothing. And a third patron could give $10. This being the case, what is their point?

For example, here is the grading curve for required courses at Seton Hall University Law School (picked at random and at least somewhat similar to curves at many other law schools):

A+ and A       15-25% (see below)

A- and B+      minimum 15% (see below)

B                       minimum 15% (see below)

B- and C+       10-25%

C and C-         10-25%

D+, D and F  5-15%

Grades in the first two categories of the foregoing grade distribution schemes should not exceed 50% of the overall class.

Grades in the first three categories of the foregoing grade distribution schemes should not exceed 70% of the overall class.

So, in Section A of Torts (100 students), Professor A could give:

5 A+s and 20 As (25%)

20 A-s and 5 B+s (25%/50% total)

20 Bs (20%/70% total)

10 B-s and 5 C+s (15%/85% total)

10 Cs (10%/95% total)

5 D+s (5%/100% total)

Meanwhile, in Section B of torts (100 students), Professor B could give:

2 A+s and 13 As (15%)

3 A-s and 12 B+s (15%/30% total)

15 Bs (15%/45% total)

5 B-s and 10 C+s (15%/60% total)

10 Cs and 15 C-s (25%/85% total)

2 D+s, 5 Ds, and 5 Fs (15%/100% total)

Now, I don't need to crunch the numbers to tell you that students in Section B are getting the short end of the stick. And maybe it is justified. Maybe, as I noted above, the students in Section A are "better" than the students in Section B. And maybe that's the point of a flexible curve. If I have a terrific set of students in a given semester, I might give grades like Professor A above. If, during another semester, I have a collection of Sweathogs, I might give grades like Professor B above. Most semesters, my grades will fall somewhere in between these 2 extremes. And while a flexible curve gives me some flexibility, it still gives me boundaries so that my grades aren't that different from the grades of a professor teaching a different section of the same course.

In an ideal world, this all makes sense. But does it make sense in the real world? From talking to colleagues, I get the general sense that the answer is "no" because I think that a course's curve tells us more about the professor than her students. I know some professors who consistently award grades at the bottom of the curve and would give lower grades if they could. Conversely, I know some professors who award grades at the top of the curve and would give higher grades if they could. In other words, some professors are "hard" graders and other professors are "easy" graders, and a student in a section with a 3.2 median is "lucky" while a student in a section with a 2.8 median is "unlucky."

But let's say that I'm wrong. Let's say that most professors modulate their curves based upon the performance of each collection of students in each class. It is still easy to imagine problems. In a torts class in fall 2011, the median on the exam is 72 in both Sections A and B. Professor A and B each create curves where the median GPA is 3.0. In the fall of 2012, the median on the exam is 76 in both Sections A and B. Professor A concludes that this was an exceptionally bright class and awards a median GPA of 3.2. Professor B concludes that this was an exceptionally easy exam and awards a median GPA of 3.0. Both professors could be correct, but they both could easily be incorrect. Maybe the students in Section B were exceptionally bright and the exam in Section A was exceptionally easy.

And there's no easy way (as I see it) for Professor A and Professor B to compare notes to ensure consistent results. First, it is pretty tough (at least for me) to determine the difficulty of a test (especially) for a class I didn't teach. I'm Professor A. A good deal of Professor B's exam deals with the attractive nuisance doctrine. Is the exam easy or difficult? I don't know. How much time did Professor B spend on the doctrine? What cases did she use? How good was the class discussion when the doctrine was covered? Second, it is difficult to judge the quality of other professors (or ourselves). Is Professor B so adept at the Socratic Method that she would make Socrates himself blush? Or is Professor B teaching contributory negligence as the majority rule?

My point in all of this is to say that it is very difficult for a professor to determine whether his section is especially bright (or dim) or whether this characteristic is shared by the class of 201# as a whole. And trying to make assumptions based upon reading the exams and exam answers from other sections isn't likely to be helpful.

So, what's my overall point? I think it is that law school curves should be less flexible.  I cited to Seton Hall's curve above, and you can see the disparity that can result between two sections under the curve. The same goes at many other law schools. For instance, at Chicago-Kent, 20% of students in Section A might get As or A-s while in Section B that percentage might be 5%. Are these and many other curves too loose, or are there good reasons for keeping law school curves as flexible as they are at many (most?) law schools? Are you an "easy" or a "tough" grader or do you significantly change your curve from semester to semester? 

-Colin Miller

Posted by Evidence ProfBlogger on September 21, 2011 at 04:09 PM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c6a7953ef01543599fd46970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference What is the Point of Law School Grading Curves if They're Not (More) Fixed?:

Comments

Welcome to ludhiana Escorts accompanies administration, we are give out call and in call escort rental administrations.

Posted by: Shaina Dsuza | Jul 29, 2021 4:01:00 AM

To Activate ESPN channel on your device, user can visit url - ESPN.com/activate, where they can activate ESPN Activation code with ESPN Account.
ESPN.com/activate

Posted by: ESPN.com/Activate | Jul 28, 2021 3:03:35 AM

ESPN is a American multinational channel. These Apps are best for streaming live cricket, live international tournaments and some unique programs . We also watch highlights of previous matches which were missed by us and also re-watch cricket matches. This app is best for cricket lovers. This app has live free channels.
ESPN.com/activate

Posted by: ESPN.com/Activate | Jul 28, 2021 3:03:09 AM

To Activate ESPN channel on your device, user can visit url - ESPN.com/activate, where they can activate ESPN Activation code with ESPN Account.
ESPN.com/activate

Posted by: Meriya Mukhhatar | Jul 27, 2021 1:04:25 AM

To Activate ESPN channel on your device, user can visit url - ESPN.com/activate, where they can activate ESPN Activation code with ESPN Account.
ESPN.com/activate

Posted by: Meriya Mukhhatar | Jul 27, 2021 1:04:25 AM

To Activate ESPN channel on your device, user can visit url - ESPN.com/activate, where they can activate ESPN Activation code with ESPN Account.
ESPN.com/activate

Posted by: Meriya Mukhhatar | Jul 27, 2021 1:04:24 AM

ESPN is a American multinational channel. These Apps are best for streaming live cricket, live international tournaments and some unique programs . We also watch highlights of previous matches which were missed by us and also re-watch cricket matches. This app is best for cricket lovers. This app has live free channels.
ESPN.com/activate

Posted by: Meriya Mukhhatar | Jul 27, 2021 1:03:58 AM

Kolkata independent model girl
http://rupshikarai18.cabanova.com

Posted by: kolkata model girls | Jul 25, 2021 12:08:03 PM

Get the latest forex broker rankings before you choose the best forex broker for you. https://www.bing.com/news/apiclick.aspx?ref=FexRss&aid=&tid=9BB77FDA801248A5AD23FDBDD5922800&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.fxrankings.com

Posted by: Spectre | Jul 24, 2021 11:05:36 AM

setup your WIFI extender

Posted by: ap.setup | Jul 23, 2021 4:09:59 AM

Pay your Simple Mobile Refill. Simple Mobile Pay Bill Online is very simple & easy to use.Simple Bill Payment is fast and secure. More info to visit;
https://prepaidphonebill.com/simple-mobile
https://prepaidphonebill.com/cricket-wireless/3-200-usd-plan
https://prepaidphonebill.com/boost-mobile/5-200-usd-plan

Posted by: Ja | Jul 22, 2021 4:54:48 AM

To activate Trend micro, make sure you already have an activation code that you’ll probably enter on the https://www.trendmicrocomactivate.com/ | . https://istartsetup.com/ij-cannon-ts3322/

Posted by: Allen wade | Jul 21, 2021 6:05:42 AM

I look forward to your blogs because they are very interesting and there is also a very visual experience to gather information.

Posted by: Yii Framework | Jul 21, 2021 2:49:27 AM

This is a very great website and I read each and every blog of yours because they are very informative.

Posted by: API Integration Services | Jul 21, 2021 2:48:49 AM

Thank you for sharing such good content, it is very unique and informational.

Posted by: PHP Development Services | Jul 21, 2021 2:48:03 AM

I am looking for good content but I can't find it on any website and then I found your website, which has very great content.

Posted by: Shopify Development Services | Jul 21, 2021 2:47:17 AM

First of all, thank you for your post. Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^ 먹튀커뮤니티

Posted by: 먹튀커뮤니티 | Jul 17, 2021 10:45:51 PM

First of all, thank you for your post. Your posts are neatly organized with the information I want, so there are plenty of resources to reference. I bookmark this site and will find your posts frequently in the future. Thanks again ^^ 먹튀커뮤니티

Posted by: 먹튀커뮤니티 | Jul 17, 2021 10:45:13 PM

Microsoft 365 is the best way to get all the apps of Office within one subscription. Microsoft365 setup offers access to the Microsoft 365 software product.

Posted by: microsoft365.com/setup | Jul 16, 2021 5:42:46 AM

Follow cricut.com/setup is the online portal that allows you to set up your Cricut machine. A mostadvanced Cricut machine is best in cutting shapes, text, and photos. It doesn’t only make cuts oncard stock or vinyl but adhesive foil, faux leather, balsa wood, and more.. ij.start canon | ij.start.canon | Mcafe.com/activate

Posted by: Mcafe.com/activate | Jul 15, 2021 2:54:23 AM

download printer drivers online, or use an installation CD, you may have received with your printer. ij.start canon

Posted by: cricut.com/setup | Jul 15, 2021 2:53:57 AM

Trend micro security is the best way to save your Connected World to all the digital part.

Posted by: www.trendmicro.com/activate | Jul 14, 2021 2:18:39 AM

If you’ve entered the McAfee activation key correctly at mcafe.com/activate and followed all instructions correctly, the key will be redeemed.

Posted by: Macfee.com/activate | Jul 13, 2021 3:29:06 AM

Incredible! This blog lo?ks exactly ?ike my o?d one!
It’s on a totally d?fferent subject b?t it ?as pretty muc?
t?e ?ame layout ?nd design. Outstanding choice ?f colors!

Posted by: 오피 | Jul 12, 2021 10:35:17 PM

At Prepaid phone Bill you can Online Mobile Phone Recharge in simple & easy way. Refill Mobile Recharge Online secure and fast. More info to visit.
https://prepaidphonebill.com/

Posted by: James Clark | Jul 12, 2021 1:22:19 AM

A most advanced Cricut machine is best in cutting shapes, text, and photos https://www.cricutcomsetup.com/.

Posted by: cricut.com/setup | Jul 9, 2021 5:23:15 AM

https://msoft365setup.com/

Posted by: microsoft365.com/setup | Jul 9, 2021 3:24:00 AM

https://www.cricutcomsetup.com

Posted by: cricut.com/setup | Jul 9, 2021 3:23:17 AM

If you are setting the printer for the first time follow the below instructions given and setup your new HP printer easily. Unbox the https://sites.google.com/setups.great-site.net/123hpojpro9025/home by removing all the packing materials and recycle the materials.
https://sites.google.com/setups.great-site.net/solutionsbrotherwindows/home printers are the all-in-one solution for office use as well as for home use.

Posted by: Max Turner | Jul 9, 2021 1:28:30 AM

Merupakan Agen Togel Online Dengan Permainan Togel Yang Paling Lengkap.
Dengan Pasaran Resmi Togel Hongkong dan Togel Singapore
Tidak Hanya Permainan Togel Dengan 10 Pasaran Resmi, AHLIBET88 Juga Memberikan Banyak Permainan Seru Lainnya

Posted by: AhliBet88 | Jul 6, 2021 9:58:04 AM

It's effortless to handle and play on gambling websites. Every beginner can easily open an account on a trusted website and add the coins to their account to play different games of their choice. The best feature of 123xbet is one can play gambling games without any special knowledge. One most important thing about a gambling website is that one has to check the people's reviews and comments about the website before investing an amount to play. dg casino Many fake websites are doing fraud with the people.

Posted by: สล็อต เครดิตฟรี ไม่ต้องแชร์ | Jul 6, 2021 4:33:55 AM

Thanks for sharing information with all of us . Who visit your website .good work and great stuff .

Posted by: Web designer | Jul 3, 2021 1:17:24 PM


An HR consultant job description might include overseeing areas such as recruitment, hiring, background and reference checks, payroll administration, benefits and compensation planning, health and safety and legal compliance. A specialist works in one or more of these areas, bringing an in-depth expertise of the area.

Posted by: Spamming Khan | Jul 3, 2021 8:52:48 AM

All businesses need a website and we are a website development company in surat that provides the best web development service so contact us.
https://www.shreedama.com/services/web-development/

Posted by: palak patel | Jul 2, 2021 5:00:59 AM

https://msoft365setup.com/ .

Posted by: https://msoft365setup.com/ | Jul 2, 2021 12:09:57 AM

A most advanced Cricut machine is best in cutting shapes, text, and photos https://www.cricutcomsetup.com/.

Posted by: cricut.com/setup | Jul 2, 2021 12:08:47 AM

https://sites.google.com/a/setups.great-site.net/https-ij-start-canon/ is the solution for easy Canon printer drivers download.
https://sites.google.com/a/setups.great-site.net/cannon-ij-setup/ | http://ijstartcanon.tilda.ws/ijstartcanonsetup/ | https://sites.google.com/setups.great-site.net/nortoncomsetup/home

Posted by: Max Turner | Jun 30, 2021 2:58:00 AM

If you are setting the printer for the first time follow the below instructions given and setup your new HP printer easily. Unbox the https://sites.google.com/setups.great-site.net/123hpojpro9025/home by removing all the packing materials and recycle the materials.
https://sites.google.com/setups.great-site.net/solutionsbrotherwindows/home printers are the all-in-one solution for office use as well as for home use.

Posted by: Max Turner | Jun 30, 2021 2:57:47 AM

If you are setting the printer for the first time follow the below instructions given and setup your new HP printer easily. Unbox the https://sites.google.com/setups.great-site.net/123hpojpro9025/home by removing all the packing materials and recycle the materials.
https://sites.google.com/setups.great-site.net/solutionsbrotherwindows/home printers are the all-in-one solution for office use as well as for home use.

Posted by: Max Turner | Jun 30, 2021 2:57:47 AM

If you are setting the printer for the first time follow the below instructions given and setup your new HP printer easily. Unbox the 123.hp.com/ojpro9025 printer by removing all the packing materials and recycle the materials.
solutions.brother.com/windows printers are the all-in-one solution for office use as well as for home use.

Posted by: Max Turner | Jun 30, 2021 2:57:10 AM

Really very happy to say that your post is very interesting to read and I never stop myself from saying something about it. You’re doing a great job. Keep it up.

Posted by: mywifiext.net | Jun 29, 2021 5:39:58 AM

123.hp.com/setup – HP printers are used everywhere in the world as it is a common product used for printing and scanning documents. HP printer is very easy to download, install and setup which you can do from official website 123hp.com/setup.
https://www123hpsetup.com/

Posted by: Meriya Mukhhatar | Jun 29, 2021 5:28:02 AM

Hulu provides the simplest way to stream entertainment to your TV. On your terms. With thousands of available channels to choose from. visit hulu.com/activate enter code now. By downloading the Hulu Plus application and activating your account, you can stream television shows and movies from the Hulu site. visit hulu.com/activate now.
https://activatehulu.com/

Posted by: Meriya Mukhhatar | Jun 29, 2021 5:27:38 AM

Enjoy exclusive Amazon Originals as well as popular movies and TV shows. Watch anytime, anywhere. Users can Activate Amazon mytv activation code with Amazon Account via amazon.com/mytv.
https://amzonukmytv.com/

Posted by: Meriya Mukhhatar | Jun 29, 2021 5:27:18 AM

Amazon.com/mytv – Amazon Prime is a paid premium package from Amazon that allows subscribers access to additional programs that are otherwise inaccessible or only available at a premium to all Amazon members in a variety of countries.
https://amaznprimeau.com/
amazon.com/mytv

Posted by: Meriya Mukhhatar | Jun 29, 2021 5:26:51 AM

I look forward to your blogs because they are very interesting and there is also a very visual experience to gather information.

Posted by: D'link router login | Jun 29, 2021 4:52:25 AM

This is a very great website and I read each and every blog of yours because they are very informative.

Posted by: login to Arris router | Jun 29, 2021 3:15:31 AM

I am looking for good content but I can't find it on any website and then I found your website, which has very great content.

Posted by: tplinkrepeater.net | Jun 29, 2021 2:42:58 AM

I found this blog very interesting and this blog has all the information, which I am looking for.

Posted by: Mesh wi-fi system | Jun 29, 2021 2:05:17 AM

I love this blog. It is very informative and it also has a very unique content.

Posted by: linksyssmartwifi.com | Jun 29, 2021 1:25:20 AM

Alltimespost is an informative blog where all the latest news and information about Technology, , Rev has been provided. Happy Birthday Quotes| KissAnime

Posted by: Alltimespost | Jun 28, 2021 10:44:43 AM

Wavlink AC1200 Setup: With Wavlink’s dual-band wireless range extender, you may progressively improve your wireless network. It allows you to experience a hassle-free installation thanks to its incredibly small and convenient design. Its sleek appearance also allows it to seamlessly mix in with your existing home or office decor.

Posted by: Wavlink AC1200 Extender Setup | Jun 28, 2021 4:59:11 AM

Automatic Slingshot Rental...The whole process was awesome! Super easy book the reservation, get the car and return it. It is so fun to drive! My father-in-law and I loved the experience! Will definitely rent from them again! Highly recommend Sling Rentals.

Posted by: Bella Johansson | Jun 28, 2021 3:00:05 AM

I am looking for good content but I can't find it on any website and then I found your website, which has very great content.

Posted by: Netgear extender login | Jun 28, 2021 2:47:29 AM

In larger areas wireless transmission is required, re.rockspace local wifi extender function as a repeater to boost the signal and fend off it from dead zone area.

Posted by: re.rockspace.local | Jun 26, 2021 1:53:27 PM

Nice Post

Posted by: Alwar Escort | Jun 26, 2021 8:35:04 AM

A Wifi Extender by tplinkrepeater.net, an American corporation, is a TP-Link Repeater installer. The device literally extends the power and range of your WiFi signal. These devices are frequently used in offices, schools, production, warehouses, supermarkets, and so on to ensure maximum internet speed in all fields.

Posted by: tplinkrepeater.net setup | Jun 25, 2021 3:16:42 PM

Amazing decision to rent a slingshot and have a fun unforgettable ride to 5th ave and Naples Pier. This place carries stick shift and Automatic Slingshot Rental. Friendly professional staff and easy check out. Highly recommend!!!

Posted by: Bella Johansson | Jun 25, 2021 11:37:36 AM

I really like reading through a post that can make people think. Also, many thanks for permitting me to comment!

Posted by: spanish dictionary | Jun 23, 2021 10:25:35 PM

If you are buying the Norton product for the first time, you may have some difficulties downloading, installing, and activating it. We have mentioned the step-by-step process for you so that you can easily download it without any problem. One can download, install and activate the Norton product by visiting the norton.com/setup. Follow the step-by-step procedure below.

Posted by: norton.com/setup | Jun 23, 2021 5:09:28 AM

Post a comment