« Depravity: Finding Meaning in Doctrine, Not Abstraction | Main | Are we “Post-Gender?” »

Monday, February 28, 2011

An Al-Kidd Reality Check: The Myth of Non-Statutory "National Security" Detention

In cross-posts at Volokh and SCOTUSblog, Orin Kerr takes issue with the government’s litigation strategy in Ashcroft v. al-Kidd, the material witness/Fourth Amendment/qualified immunity appeal in which the Supreme Court is set to hear argument on Wednesday. Orin’s argument is worth reading in full, but I will focus on his principal point -- that, when it comes to the substantive Fourth Amendment question in the case, "DOJ is making an argument with one arm tied behind its back.” I don’t think that’s right. Instead, as I explain below the fold, DOJ does not, in fact, have available the alternative “national security detention” argument that Orin believes it is avoiding.

As Orin notes, DOJ's merits-based argument is argument is that because it has available a criminal law enforcement justification for detaining someone under the material witness statute, it does not violate the Fourth Amendment if the government’s “real” reason for the detention is instead a national security objective, such as interrogating the detainee to discover if he has information about possible future national security threats.

What Orin finds curious is that DOJ is not arguing that the national security justification is itself an independent ground for the detention. As Orin puts it, “DOJ never makes the argument that its use of the material witness statute for national security reasons is permitted by its national security detention powers. . . . DOJ is arguing that the Court shouldn’t even look at its non-law-enforcement purpose and therefore shouldn’t get into its national security powers. . . ." This choice puzzles Orin. He writes that “[i]t’s not clear to me why DOJ has limited its argument in this way. But . . . [t]he Justices presumably will want to know . . . what DOJ thinks its national security powers are.” What this overlooks is that the government is probably forgoing such an argument because it does not have any such “national security” power to detain a U.S. citizen for over two weeks (as happened to al-Kidd).  Indeed, I think it's fairly clear that neither the Constitution nor any federal statute affords the government such authority, at least in this case.

For starters, federal law specifically forbids it. The so-called Non-Detention Act, 18 U.S.C. § 4001(a), provides that “[n]o citizen shall be imprisoned or otherwise detained by the United States except pursuant to an Act of Congress.” In Hamdi, the government argued that this prohibition does not apply to military detention. The Court did not specifically rule on that question, but as I wrote way back when, its earlier decision in Howe v. Smith had held that “[t]his argument . . . fails to give adequate weight to the plain language of § 4001(a) proscribing detention of any kind by the United States, absent a congressional grant of authority to detain.”

To be sure, as Hamdi itself suggests, the Non-Detention Act is merely a baseline restriction: It does not prevent Congress from authorizing “national security detention.” (Indeed, the Hamdi Court went on to hold that Hamdi’s detention was authorized by the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force.) The material witness statute might well provide such authority in some cases – the government’s argument is that it did so in the al-Kidd case. Orin’s puzzlement, however, is why DOJ is not also citing a stand-alone “national security” basis for al-Kidd's detention, rather than falling back on the material witness statute.

The reason for DOJ's reticence on that score is that Congress has not afforded the Executive such an authority. Section 412 of the USA PATRIOT Act does authorize the detention of non-citizens suspected of terrorism-related activities for up to seven days, before the detainee must either be (1) charged with a crime; (2) placed in removal proceedings; or (3) released. But that authority would not help in al-Kidd, both because he is a citizen and because his detention more than doubled the seven-day statutory limit. Moreover, as Orin himself notes, DOJ urged Congress during the debate over the PATRIOT Act to enact a broader statute authorizing national security detentions that might cover the case here, but that “proposal proved controversial and was never passed.”

It might be argued instead that the AUMF authorizes the very “national security detention” Orin contemplates. It is very much an open question whether the AUMF does (and constitutionally could) authorize the detention of individuals, especially U.S. persons, who are apprehended within the United States and alleged to be enemy forces, among the persons covered by the terms of the AUMF. That was the question raised in both the Padilla (U.S. citizen) and al-Marri (lawfully resident non-citizen) cases, which the Supreme Court did not resolve because the government returned the two detainees to criminal custody. But whatever the government's national security detention authority might be as to members of enemy forces captured inside the United States, the AUMF cannot be of assistance here; the government is not alleging that al-Kidd is part of enemy forces, or otherwise covered in any way by the terms of the AUMF.

Nor am I aware of any extant statutory authority for long-term “national security detention” beyond what the material witness statute, the USA PATRIOT Act (for non-citizens), and the AUMF provide. Together with the prohibition of the Non-Detention Act, this absence of statutory authority explains why the government’s sole argument for its authority to detain al-Kidd is based on the material witness statute. To be fair, If I’m reading his posts correctly, Orin appears to think that the Fourth Amendment itself might provide the government with the authority that the U.S. Code does not for a long-term “national security” detention of a U.S. citizen. But I had always understood the Fourth Amendment as only limiting the government’s power to seize persons – not as creating such powers.

In short, then, it seems to me that the Justice Department isn’t forgoing any important arguments here. Leaving aside whether or not former Attorney General Ashcroft is entitled to qualified immunity, the underlying merits issue is whether the material witness statute authorized al-Kidd’s detention -- and, if it did, whether that detention nevertheless violated the Fourth Amendment if the government’s motives were pretextual in the way al-Kidd alleges (allegations that must be taken as true at this stage of the litigation). It's still an important and tricky case to be sure, but I just don't see Orin's dog that didn't bark...

Update: Orin's posted a thoughtful reply, for which I'm quite thankful. I agree with Orin that Virginia v. Moore appears to stand for the (in my view, not entirely obvious) proposition that the mere fact that a seizure is ultra vires is not conclusive of its reasonableness for Fourth Amendment purposes. At the risk of drawing out this exchange longer than is merited, Orin's response provokes two additional thoughts on my end:

First, crystallizing the argument as Orin has only reinforces to me the reasons why DOJ didn't make it part of their argument on the merits before the Supreme Court. After all, to make the argument that al-Kidd's seizure was reasonable on national security grounds, DOJ would have to concede that it had nothing whatsoever to do with the material witness statute, since it's hardly an alternative theory that fits the same facts. So framed, the government would be litigating the case on even weaker terrain--conceding a statutory violation and resting everything on Moore, where the issue was the legality of the initial arrest, rather than the subsequent detention.

Second, and related, I can't imagine the Justices will see the issue here as settled by Moore. It's one thing to argue that certain seizures are consistent with the Fourth Amendment regardless of whether they're authorized by statute, but that's in the short term (as in Moore). It's another thing entirely to think that the Fourth Amendment would also tolerate continuing detention beyond the initial seizure in the face of contrary statutory authority -- especially where, as here, a federal statute specifically forbids precisely that category of detention (i.e., detention without statutory authority). Of course, one response is that it's difficult to draw the line between what the Fourth Amendment might tolerate initially and what it won't abide in the long term, but isn't that the entire point of the 48-hour rule articulated by the Court in County of Riverside? I'm not the criminal procedure expert that Orin is, but it strikes me that Moore would be irreconcilable with County of Riverside if it stood for the proposition that the Fourth Amendment tolerates detention past 48 hours in the absence of other, statutory authority. 

Given that, although I appreciate what Orin's arguing, I still can't see how the wiser course for DOJ would have been to argue for "national security" detention.

Posted by Steve Vladeck on February 28, 2011 at 01:42 AM in Blogging, Constitutional thoughts, Criminal Law, Current Affairs, Steve Vladeck | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference An Al-Kidd Reality Check: The Myth of Non-Statutory "National Security" Detention:


doramas coreanas, chinos, Tailandia, Japones, Estrenos Doramas con subtítulos en español gratis
Espanol doramas

Posted by: koreantv | Aug 2, 2021 1:58:48 AM

Watch Online All old and New Episode Free. turkish series with english subtitles
Watch Turkish Series with English Subtitles Online for Free without Registration.

Posted by: turksh | Aug 2, 2021 1:57:06 AM

Its very amazing article in these site. Thanks to admin

Posted by: GB WhatsApp Pro | Aug 1, 2021 5:57:25 AM

Great Information thanks for sharing bro keep it up.

Posted by: Anupama | Jul 28, 2021 9:54:31 AM

Greag Content

Posted by: Natalie Krauß | Jul 27, 2021 3:52:56 AM

ISO 27001 Certification in Dubai is the international standard that describes best follow for a data Security Management System (ISMS). the standard takes a risk-based approach to data security, requiring organizations to identify threats to their company then adopt appropriate controls across their business to tackle them.

Posted by: certvalue | Jul 26, 2021 5:15:34 AM

Obligation at hand is an activity game that has a wide scope of fun chasing after the world. The plot of this activity-based game is identified with the battle of Stalingrad against German powers where players kill a huge number and zombies to rank, open weapons, characters, and get more elevated levels. apkvow.com

Posted by: apkvow.com | Jul 20, 2021 11:37:00 AM

Thats a very importent arctial for me thanku for share pinoy Tv

Posted by: pinoys1tv | Jul 17, 2021 6:29:03 AM


Posted by: clicksud | Jul 17, 2021 6:05:14 AM

Best Website for Watching colors TV shows is Bigg Boss 15 Live

Posted by: Bigg Boss 15 Live | Jul 15, 2021 10:52:16 AM

We are a domiciliary consideration office. Our point is to give care and backing administrations to our customers which surpass administrative consideration necessities and that are best in class. painter and decorator

Posted by: painter and decorator | Jul 14, 2021 6:39:07 PM

All latest news about tamildhool exclusive at portal.

Posted by: tamildhool | Jun 28, 2021 4:21:58 PM

This is very interesting post.I will bookmark your blog to my favorites. https://kissasiane.com/

Posted by: Drama Cool | Jun 26, 2021 11:32:33 PM

Nice post. Keep it up

Posted by: Kdrama | Jun 22, 2021 4:52:00 AM

Watch Bigg Boss 15 Hindi Tv Show This is an Indian Reality Tv game show.
The host of this show Salman Khan the show was On-Air Colors Tv.

Bigg Boss 15 Live

Posted by: Bigg Boss 15 Live | Jun 17, 2021 8:50:58 AM

Yonkers Taxi is operational under the umbrella of Empire Ride Inc. since 2017 and it is viewed as a standout amongst other Yonkers Cab Companies. Our Satisfied clients with positive surveys will assist you with settling on a savvy choice.

Posted by: Westchester car service | Jun 11, 2021 11:14:21 AM

Also share it with your friends and family so they can also enjoy watching all dfm2u drama Series,Filem, Pencuri movie
Melayu Filem,

Tonton Tv3 Live
kepala bergetar

Posted by: dfm2u drama online | Jun 3, 2021 5:42:06 PM

Watch Your favorite DramaCool Tv Shows Online Free in HD Quality our Official website tvdramacool.com provide English Sub DramaCool at Kissasian Tv series Online Episode Free.

Posted by: DRAMMA COOL | Jun 1, 2021 2:56:35 AM

Watch Your favorite DramaCool Tv Shows Online Free in HD Quality our Official website tvdramacool.com provide English Sub DramaCool at Kissasian Tv series Online Episode Free.

Posted by: DRAMMA COOL | Jun 1, 2021 2:56:19 AM

Watch Molkki All Episodes Online Free, मोलक्की YoDesi TV Serial Molkki Today Episode free at dailymotion Full Episodes In HD Quality.
molkki tv serial,
Molkki TV drama

Posted by: Molkki | May 31, 2021 3:38:39 AM

pyaar ke uss paar Watch Online All Indian TV Shows, Dramas, desi serials Reality Shows on Desi TV Box, Color TV and Zee TV brings latest episode watch live on our website. More information email us [email protected]

Posted by: Pyaar ke Uss Paar | May 31, 2021 3:37:46 AM

You can bookmark our website for Fresh Content. pinoyflixtambayan first drama site to release the latest episodes of All new Dramas.

Posted by: pinoyflix | May 31, 2021 1:56:53 AM

I have read the blog and i really like it.
The way you portrait the blog is outstanding like your work
Best Regards : Pinoy Tambayan

Posted by: pinoy Tambayan | May 29, 2021 4:59:49 PM

Good article, I like it. Hope you keep making interesting articles like this.

Posted by: poker deposit pulsa | May 29, 2021 8:27:27 AM

great boss

Posted by: kissanime | May 29, 2021 6:41:43 AM

i love your blog

Posted by: kissanime | May 29, 2021 6:36:20 AM

Also share it with your friends and family so they can also enjoy watching all https://pencurimoviedfm2u.com/

Posted by: dfm2u drama online | May 27, 2021 3:37:52 PM

Always enjoy to Watch free TV shows for your entertainment Bigg Boss 15 Episodes

Posted by: Bigg Boss 15 Episodes | May 24, 2021 10:46:10 AM

You are really doing a good job and keep it up and Bigg boss 15 is an
hindi drama reality tv show and if you want to watch live episodes in hd quality
visit this website. It will be telecasted at the end of September 2021.
bigg boss 15 live
bigg boss 15 all episodes
download bigg boss 15

Posted by: Iqrar iqrar Abbas | May 23, 2021 3:37:00 AM

you write that post really well and also you ended really well keep on doing that people loving it.
Bawara Dil episode

Posted by: Bawara Dil | May 22, 2021 11:20:54 AM

Watch Pinoyflix tambayan At Lambingan Watch all your favorite Pinoy Lambingan And Lambingan for free. Pinoy Entertainment shows Pinoy news shows, Pinoy Tv Drama replay, Pinoy Teleserye Replay, Pinoy Tv, Pinoy Channel, Tambayan At Lambingan, Pinoy Entertainment Replays.
Pinoy Teleserye
Pinoy Tambayan
Pinoy Lambingan
Pinoy Channel

Watch online Pinoy tambayan , Pinoy lambingan , Pinoy ako , Pinoy tv , Pinoy channel , Pinoy1tv , Tfc Tv , Pinoy teleserye and Teleserye shows.
Lambingan is one of the Pinoy Tv term to search online Filipino Tv Shows. Those viewers who are residing outside of Philippines use to search online Pinoy Lambingan or Lambingan Tv Shows

Posted by: pinoy Channel | May 21, 2021 7:27:34 AM

Udaariyaan Is Indian Tv Channel Sony Tv Dramas By
Hindi Channel Star Plus Colors Tv Sony tv All Dramas free in hd Quality.

Udaariyaan Mx Player

Posted by: Udaariyaan Mx Player | May 20, 2021 9:41:46 AM

Watch Bigg Boss 15 Hindi Tv Show This is an Indian Reality Tv game show.
The host of this show Salman Khan the show was On-Air Colors Tv.

Bigg Boss 15 Online

Posted by: Bigg Boss 15 Online | May 16, 2021 2:55:40 PM

i love to read your article about national security

Posted by: Tamil Movie | May 14, 2021 5:32:53 PM

wow absolutely gorgeous stuff good work

Posted by: Shaurya Aur Anokhi Ki Kahani | May 14, 2021 5:31:34 PM

Waooo Thats Amazing man YOU Shared Awesome INFO Really Greatful TO You.

Posted by: Mtv Splitsvilla X3 | Apr 22, 2021 7:49:10 PM

Bigg Boss 15 Latest Episode is going to start from October 2021, This show could be late due to corona again
but Salman Khan and team colors tv will manage to set it on time, Audition will be on May 2021.

Posted by: Bigg Boss 15 Online | Apr 20, 2021 10:48:38 PM

Teleserye.su - Watch your favorite Pinoy Tambayan, Pinoy Channel, Pinoy Teleserye Replay, Pinoy TV Series and Pinoy TV Shows online for free! Pinoy Teleserye

Posted by: pinoy teleserye | Apr 12, 2021 8:32:12 AM

A really nice blog where we can found useful information.Thanks you.

Posted by: Qurbaan Hua | Apr 12, 2021 2:28:31 AM

Hey,Thats Nice Article Which YOU Make Very Easy TO Understand Thanks Buddy.

Posted by: Mehndi Hai Rachne Wali | Apr 10, 2021 2:43:08 PM

See below for more information regarding how to obtain these training materials.
This just frustrated me, and that i wound up
having behavioral problems in college. The teachings they learn will be used for a very long time.

Posted by: Ghum Hai Kisi Ke Pyaar Mein | Mar 31, 2021 7:47:02 AM

陸劇 線上看, 韓劇 線上看, 台劇 線上看, 港劇 線上看, 日劇 線上看, 綜藝 線上看, 泰劇 線上看. Maplestage, https://8maple.su 楓林网, 楓林, 風林網, 瘦楓林網, 風林往, 8maple, 風鈴網, 風林, 風鈴往, 枫林网, Dramaq.

Posted by: 楓林網 | Mar 29, 2021 7:38:42 PM

There are many channels in Pinoy that can provide high-quality entertainment programs for domestic and foreign audiences. The Pinoy Teleserye broadcasts some Pinoy Teleserye and offers sessions that bring together families from the Philippines at an enjoyable time.

Posted by: Pinoy Teleserye | Mar 19, 2021 12:36:34 PM

Our website offers you the best content about Pinoy HD Replay and we want you to see the Pinoy Lambingan. It gives you the right channel for your favorite TV series. Pinoy Tambayan

Posted by: Pinoy HD Replay | Mar 19, 2021 12:35:43 PM

This site gives you all content provided by Pinoy HD Tv. Pinoy is a site where you can watch and download all TV shows for free. Pinoy Tv

Posted by: Pinoy HD Tv | Mar 19, 2021 12:35:11 PM

Watch Pinoy Tambayan Lambingan on your favorite Teleserye Replay. Many websites have been published on the Pinoy Lambingan network. Pinoy Teleserye

Posted by: Teleserye Replay | Mar 19, 2021 12:34:24 PM

This site provides you with all the content Pinoy Tv has provided. It is a site where you can away with all the Pinoy Teleserye and gets them for free. Pinoy Lambingan

Posted by: Pinoy Teleserye | Mar 19, 2021 12:33:39 PM

The Pinoy Channel broadcasts some Pinoy HD Teleserye and offers sessions that bring together families from the Philippines at an enjoyable time. Pinoy Channel

Posted by: Pinoy HD Teleserye | Mar 19, 2021 12:32:36 PM

Here is some magic. Pinoy Teleserye gives you something that makes you feel at home and gives you the warmth of your home environment! Yes! We are talking about Filipino online programs. Pinoy Lambingan

Posted by: Pinoy Teleserye | Mar 19, 2021 12:31:47 PM

Here is some magic. Pinoy Teleserye gives you something that makes you feel at home and gives you the warmth of your home environment! Yes! We are talking about Filipino online programs. Pinoy Lambingan

Posted by: Pinoy Teleserye | Mar 19, 2021 12:31:46 PM

Now that you are not at home or missing one of your favorite Pinoy Lambingan or dramas, do not worry at all because they are all together in one click. Pinoy Lambingan

Posted by: Pinoy Lambingan | Mar 19, 2021 12:31:10 PM

Both networks are very sweet and beautiful on Pinoy Channel in the Philippines. Pinoy TV shows have been updated according to the specific theme released on the official website and the videos are shared on the official website. Pinoy Lambingan

Posted by: Pinoy Channel | Mar 19, 2021 12:28:57 PM

This site provides you with all the content created by Pinoy Lambingan. The Pinoy Tv Shows Channel is a place to get away from all the boring TV shows. Pinoy Tv

Posted by: Pinoy Tv | Mar 19, 2021 12:26:54 PM

We will provide you with the right rental, but only for the appropriate TV characters. You can also watch the Pinoy HD playback, updated daily, according to the above controls. Pinoy Tv

Posted by: Pinoy HD | Mar 19, 2021 12:25:54 PM

Great article. I'm dealing with some of these issues as well..

desi serial

Posted by: desi serial | Mar 18, 2021 8:59:17 AM

Dramacool | Asian Drama, Movies and K Shows English Subbed on Dramacool the Entertainment platform

Posted by: Dramacool | Mar 12, 2021 11:50:57 AM

Maplestage,https://8maple.su 8maple, Dramaq.

Posted by: 楓林網 | Mar 8, 2021 6:56:18 PM

陸劇 線上看, 韓劇 線上看, 台劇 線上看, 港劇 線上看, 日劇 線上看, 綜藝 線上看, 泰劇 線上看. Maplestage, 楓林网, 楓林, 風林網, 瘦楓林網, 風林往, 8maple, 風鈴網, 風林, 風鈴往, 枫林网, Dramaq.

Posted by: 楓林網 | Mar 8, 2021 6:52:47 PM

Watch All Indian Dramas Online...!

Posted by: Tera Yaar Hoon Main | Mar 7, 2021 11:39:57 PM

Asian Drama, Watch drama asian Online for free releases in Korean, Japanese, Taiwanese, Thailand and Chinese English subtitle Drama Cool dramacool

Posted by: DramaCool | Mar 5, 2021 6:05:34 AM

The comments to this entry are closed.