« Depravity: Finding Meaning in Doctrine, Not Abstraction | Main | Are we “Post-Gender?” »

Monday, February 28, 2011

An Al-Kidd Reality Check: The Myth of Non-Statutory "National Security" Detention

In cross-posts at Volokh and SCOTUSblog, Orin Kerr takes issue with the government’s litigation strategy in Ashcroft v. al-Kidd, the material witness/Fourth Amendment/qualified immunity appeal in which the Supreme Court is set to hear argument on Wednesday. Orin’s argument is worth reading in full, but I will focus on his principal point -- that, when it comes to the substantive Fourth Amendment question in the case, "DOJ is making an argument with one arm tied behind its back.” I don’t think that’s right. Instead, as I explain below the fold, DOJ does not, in fact, have available the alternative “national security detention” argument that Orin believes it is avoiding.

As Orin notes, DOJ's merits-based argument is argument is that because it has available a criminal law enforcement justification for detaining someone under the material witness statute, it does not violate the Fourth Amendment if the government’s “real” reason for the detention is instead a national security objective, such as interrogating the detainee to discover if he has information about possible future national security threats.

What Orin finds curious is that DOJ is not arguing that the national security justification is itself an independent ground for the detention. As Orin puts it, “DOJ never makes the argument that its use of the material witness statute for national security reasons is permitted by its national security detention powers. . . . DOJ is arguing that the Court shouldn’t even look at its non-law-enforcement purpose and therefore shouldn’t get into its national security powers. . . ." This choice puzzles Orin. He writes that “[i]t’s not clear to me why DOJ has limited its argument in this way. But . . . [t]he Justices presumably will want to know . . . what DOJ thinks its national security powers are.” What this overlooks is that the government is probably forgoing such an argument because it does not have any such “national security” power to detain a U.S. citizen for over two weeks (as happened to al-Kidd).  Indeed, I think it's fairly clear that neither the Constitution nor any federal statute affords the government such authority, at least in this case.

For starters, federal law specifically forbids it. The so-called Non-Detention Act, 18 U.S.C. § 4001(a), provides that “[n]o citizen shall be imprisoned or otherwise detained by the United States except pursuant to an Act of Congress.” In Hamdi, the government argued that this prohibition does not apply to military detention. The Court did not specifically rule on that question, but as I wrote way back when, its earlier decision in Howe v. Smith had held that “[t]his argument . . . fails to give adequate weight to the plain language of § 4001(a) proscribing detention of any kind by the United States, absent a congressional grant of authority to detain.”

To be sure, as Hamdi itself suggests, the Non-Detention Act is merely a baseline restriction: It does not prevent Congress from authorizing “national security detention.” (Indeed, the Hamdi Court went on to hold that Hamdi’s detention was authorized by the 2001 Authorization for Use of Military Force.) The material witness statute might well provide such authority in some cases – the government’s argument is that it did so in the al-Kidd case. Orin’s puzzlement, however, is why DOJ is not also citing a stand-alone “national security” basis for al-Kidd's detention, rather than falling back on the material witness statute.

The reason for DOJ's reticence on that score is that Congress has not afforded the Executive such an authority. Section 412 of the USA PATRIOT Act does authorize the detention of non-citizens suspected of terrorism-related activities for up to seven days, before the detainee must either be (1) charged with a crime; (2) placed in removal proceedings; or (3) released. But that authority would not help in al-Kidd, both because he is a citizen and because his detention more than doubled the seven-day statutory limit. Moreover, as Orin himself notes, DOJ urged Congress during the debate over the PATRIOT Act to enact a broader statute authorizing national security detentions that might cover the case here, but that “proposal proved controversial and was never passed.”

It might be argued instead that the AUMF authorizes the very “national security detention” Orin contemplates. It is very much an open question whether the AUMF does (and constitutionally could) authorize the detention of individuals, especially U.S. persons, who are apprehended within the United States and alleged to be enemy forces, among the persons covered by the terms of the AUMF. That was the question raised in both the Padilla (U.S. citizen) and al-Marri (lawfully resident non-citizen) cases, which the Supreme Court did not resolve because the government returned the two detainees to criminal custody. But whatever the government's national security detention authority might be as to members of enemy forces captured inside the United States, the AUMF cannot be of assistance here; the government is not alleging that al-Kidd is part of enemy forces, or otherwise covered in any way by the terms of the AUMF.

Nor am I aware of any extant statutory authority for long-term “national security detention” beyond what the material witness statute, the USA PATRIOT Act (for non-citizens), and the AUMF provide. Together with the prohibition of the Non-Detention Act, this absence of statutory authority explains why the government’s sole argument for its authority to detain al-Kidd is based on the material witness statute. To be fair, If I’m reading his posts correctly, Orin appears to think that the Fourth Amendment itself might provide the government with the authority that the U.S. Code does not for a long-term “national security” detention of a U.S. citizen. But I had always understood the Fourth Amendment as only limiting the government’s power to seize persons – not as creating such powers.

In short, then, it seems to me that the Justice Department isn’t forgoing any important arguments here. Leaving aside whether or not former Attorney General Ashcroft is entitled to qualified immunity, the underlying merits issue is whether the material witness statute authorized al-Kidd’s detention -- and, if it did, whether that detention nevertheless violated the Fourth Amendment if the government’s motives were pretextual in the way al-Kidd alleges (allegations that must be taken as true at this stage of the litigation). It's still an important and tricky case to be sure, but I just don't see Orin's dog that didn't bark...


Update: Orin's posted a thoughtful reply, for which I'm quite thankful. I agree with Orin that Virginia v. Moore appears to stand for the (in my view, not entirely obvious) proposition that the mere fact that a seizure is ultra vires is not conclusive of its reasonableness for Fourth Amendment purposes. At the risk of drawing out this exchange longer than is merited, Orin's response provokes two additional thoughts on my end:

First, crystallizing the argument as Orin has only reinforces to me the reasons why DOJ didn't make it part of their argument on the merits before the Supreme Court. After all, to make the argument that al-Kidd's seizure was reasonable on national security grounds, DOJ would have to concede that it had nothing whatsoever to do with the material witness statute, since it's hardly an alternative theory that fits the same facts. So framed, the government would be litigating the case on even weaker terrain--conceding a statutory violation and resting everything on Moore, where the issue was the legality of the initial arrest, rather than the subsequent detention.

Second, and related, I can't imagine the Justices will see the issue here as settled by Moore. It's one thing to argue that certain seizures are consistent with the Fourth Amendment regardless of whether they're authorized by statute, but that's in the short term (as in Moore). It's another thing entirely to think that the Fourth Amendment would also tolerate continuing detention beyond the initial seizure in the face of contrary statutory authority -- especially where, as here, a federal statute specifically forbids precisely that category of detention (i.e., detention without statutory authority). Of course, one response is that it's difficult to draw the line between what the Fourth Amendment might tolerate initially and what it won't abide in the long term, but isn't that the entire point of the 48-hour rule articulated by the Court in County of Riverside? I'm not the criminal procedure expert that Orin is, but it strikes me that Moore would be irreconcilable with County of Riverside if it stood for the proposition that the Fourth Amendment tolerates detention past 48 hours in the absence of other, statutory authority. 

Given that, although I appreciate what Orin's arguing, I still can't see how the wiser course for DOJ would have been to argue for "national security" detention.

Posted by Steve Vladeck on February 28, 2011 at 01:42 AM in Blogging, Constitutional thoughts, Criminal Law, Current Affairs, Steve Vladeck | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c6a7953ef0147e2c60402970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference An Al-Kidd Reality Check: The Myth of Non-Statutory "National Security" Detention:

Comments

Awesome content. Thanks for posting this article.

Posted by: Kwalitycert | Jan 22, 2021 12:34:08 AM

Awesome content. Thanks for posting this article.

Posted by: Kwalitycert | Jan 22, 2021 12:32:40 AM

Awesome information. Thanks for posting this article.

Posted by: Usha | Jan 22, 2021 12:30:33 AM

To watch free Asian dramas on your browser visit. kissasian

Posted by: kissasian | Jan 21, 2021 5:02:16 AM

Dramacool | Asian Drama, Movies and K Shows English Subbed

Posted by: True Beauty (2020) | Jan 16, 2021 12:30:26 AM

Thanks for your explanation. It gives us a clear view of the current situation in your country.

Bookkeeping Services Singapore

Posted by: Bookkeeping Singapore | Jan 14, 2021 11:18:36 AM

Watch HD Pinoy Tv Show Online For Free . You Can Download Pinoy Tambayan Replay Show Just In One Click .

Posted by: pinoy tv show online | Jan 8, 2021 12:42:20 PM

eally enjoy reading this post because there are so many great and very interesting information is mention in this post.

very nice this site

Posted by: best-mouse.com | Dec 29, 2020 1:20:03 AM

Click on the link https://lsresult.in/ to Download and view Lottery sambad result online. sambad today lottery result online PDF. Check daily Lottery Sambad Result 11:55 AM, 4:00 PM and 8:00 PM. As you now lottery sambad draw held 3 times a daw once at 11:55 AM Second time 4PM and 3rd Time 8PM.

Posted by: Lottery Sambad | Dec 22, 2020 5:07:10 AM

Pinoy Lambingan Orihinal na may Pinoy Tv Replay. Pinoy Teleserye, Pinoy Tambayan, Pinoy ako, Pinoy Channel, Pinoy TV Shows, Pinoy Network Lambingan.

Posted by: pinoy lambingan | Dec 21, 2020 3:38:45 PM

Right now almost, every individuals get shift in the SMS in order to Whatapps, which is a result of unlimited therapeutic massage, and permit sharing the actual photos in order to national in order to international. In the same, you will find number associated with way how the children obtain misuse along with closed one in the teen grow older.

Posted by: Colors tv serial | Dec 21, 2020 2:59:34 PM

Watch all your favorite kissanimeru online for free! Our website can provide you with free gogoanime Full Episode of 9anime or kissanime and official kissanime.

Posted by: kissanimeru | Dec 19, 2020 10:51:29 AM

Watch all your favorite kissanime online for free! Our website can provide you with free gogoanime Full Episode of 9anime or kissanimeru and official kissanime.

Posted by: kissanime | Dec 19, 2020 10:51:16 AM

The Lottery Sambad today result is uploaded in two different HD file formats the PDF and DBF formats. Both are downloadable and also you can view it online on our website. https://lotterysambadresults.mobi/ Lottery Sambad Today Result 4pm are also uploaded you can check it by clicking on the above button. Quick Guide to Download Lottery Sambad Result.

Posted by: Lottery Sambad | Dec 14, 2020 4:25:46 AM

The Lottery Sambad today result is uploaded in two different HD file formats the PDF and DBF formats. Both are downloadable and also you can view it online on our website. https://lotterysambadresults.mobi/ Lottery Sambad Today Result 4pm are also uploaded you can check it by clicking on the above button. Quick Guide to Download Lottery Sambad Result.

Posted by: Lottery Sambad | Dec 14, 2020 4:25:45 AM

It’s hard to come by experienced people about this subject, but you seem like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks

Posted by: Ishq Mein Marjawan 2 | Dec 9, 2020 1:12:01 PM

I have been lately thinking the same thing personally recently. Happy to find someone on precisely the exact same wavelength! Wonderful article.

Posted by: Saath nibhaana saathiya 2 | Dec 8, 2020 4:29:19 PM

I have been lately thinking the same thing personally recently. Happy to find someone on precisely the exact same wavelength! Wonderful article.

Posted by: Apne TV Hindi Serial | Dec 8, 2020 3:54:51 PM

We are Professional academic online essay typer Services with a qualified of Subject Matter Experts who ensure you get the best assignments.

Posted by: colors tv | Dec 8, 2020 3:52:05 PM

I have been lately thinking the same thing personally recently. Happy to find someone on precisely the exact same wavelength! Wonderful article.

Posted by: Hindi tv serials | Dec 8, 2020 3:50:59 PM

I have been lately thinking the same thing personally recently. Happy to find someone on precisely the exact same wavelength! Wonderful article. https://raazmahal.net/

Posted by: Shaadi Mubarak | Dec 1, 2020 5:09:55 PM

It was actually very good job. I truly enjoy your ideas. I personally enjoys to your own work. Your essay is quite impressive and beneficial for all of us. . . Thank you=https://diljaisedhadke.com/

Posted by: Anupama | Dec 1, 2020 5:08:03 PM


I've bookmarked this, what a fantastic info! Thank you most. Now to search the opportunity to scan all them.

Excellent post, I found many educational things here, thankyou
Ghum Hai Kisi Ke Pyaar Mein

Posted by: Ghum Hai Kisi Ke Pyaar Mein | Dec 1, 2020 5:06:36 PM

Thank you for sharing exceptional informations. Your site is quite cool. I am impressed with the details you have on this website. It shows how well you comprehend this topic. Bookmarked this web page, will return for more posts. I discovered only the advice that I searched all around the area and just could not encounter. What a fantastic web-site.

Yeh Hai Chahatein

Posted by: Yeh Hai Chahatein | Dec 1, 2020 5:04:21 PM

Wow, so why should anyone expect the Gartner APM MQ, In the past year or currently moving forward?!?

This has to be a total conflict of interest, so you have to tell me that the 2 people he has named Will Cappelli and Cameron wouldn’t be now heavily influenced by the Jonah guy in his brand new perch at AppDynamics? I sort of feel duped and this situation seems dirty. This guy Jonah leaving to take a cushy VP job at a business he allegedly provided unbiased analysis for the previous 4 decades, why should anybody believe a word coming from these documents.

Posted by: Desi Serials | Nov 27, 2020 4:07:50 PM

Normally I don’t read post on blogs, but I would like to say that this write-up very forced me to check out and do it! Your writing taste has been amazed me. Thanks, quite nice article.

Posted by: Watch Ishq Mein Marjawan 2 Online | Nov 27, 2020 12:49:44 AM

Watch All time best Hindi TV show Saath Nibhaana Saathiya 2 by Special Channel.

Posted by: Saath Nibhaana Saathiya 2 | Nov 26, 2020 3:47:26 AM

Thank you for a great site for us to read and educate.

Posted by: Apne Tv | Nov 25, 2020 7:49:50 PM

Contact Now Yahoo support number Canada Dial-up +1-800-882-0832 to get the issue resolved related with yahoo Mail. Also fine more details on our website:-
https://webslivesupport.com/yahoo-customer-support/


yahoo support canada,yahoo number canada,yahoo support number canada

Posted by: smith | Nov 24, 2020 4:46:26 PM

Healthful self-esteem is directly associated with rational behavior, eventfulness, foresight, creativity, freedom, flexibility, the capacity to accept change, the tendency to admit errors, and cooperation. The stronger and healthier we are, the better prepared we are to deal with problems in our personal and professional lives. To learn more on self-esteem, refer to the iranmodir site.

Posted by: Aladdin | Nov 23, 2020 7:51:08 PM

Your post was great. I was looking for this article and I am very happy.

Wow, so why should anyone expect the Gartner APM MQ, In the past year or currently moving forward?!?

This has to be a total conflict of interest, so you have to tell me that the 2 people he has named Will Cappelli and Cameron wouldn't be now heavily influenced by the Jonah guy in his brand new perch at AppDynamics? I sort of feel duped and this situation seems dirty. This guy Jonah leaving to take a cushy VP job at a business he allegedly provided unbiased analysis for the previous 4 decades, why should anybody believe a word coming from these documents. Thanke you for good post.

Bigg Boss 14 Colors Tv Show Watch Full Episodes

Posted by: Bigg Boss 14 | Nov 23, 2020 4:58:04 PM

An impressive share! I have just forwarded this onto a coworker who had been conducting a little homework on this.

Posted by: PINOY TV SHOW REPLAY | Nov 19, 2020 7:40:04 AM


Default Ip Can be used to Login Trendnet Router Web Console to Manage Settings

Posted by: Pinoy Tv Lambingan | Nov 19, 2020 7:36:55 AM

Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thank you, However I am having difficulties with your RSS. I don’t understand the reason why I cannot join it. Is there anybody else having the same RSS issues? Anybody who knows the answer will you kindly respond? Thanks!!

Posted by: Pinoy Tv | Nov 19, 2020 7:34:49 AM

Watch Pinoy tv show online on mobile .

Posted by: Pinoy Tv Lambingan | Nov 19, 2020 5:21:12 AM

Oh my goodness! Incredible article dude! Thank you, However I am having difficulties with your RSS. I don’t understand the reason why I cannot join it. Is there anybody else having the same RSS issues? Anybody who knows the answer will you kindly respond? Thanks!!
indrma

Posted by: indrama | Nov 16, 2020 5:32:45 AM

The Admin Of indrma Website Is very Hard Working. He Upload daily Best Dramas Of All Country So Please Visit His website And Bookmark his website And Also Download Your Favourite Dramas

Posted by: indrama | Nov 16, 2020 4:55:25 AM

Watch Bigg Boss 14 All Episodes...!

Posted by: Bigg Boss 14 | Nov 8, 2020 12:38:48 PM

Colors TV is providing the best TV show Pinjara Khubsurti Ka By Ekta Kapoor. You can watch and download easily without any cost.

Posted by: Pinjara Khubsurti Ka | Nov 5, 2020 7:12:36 AM

At KS Executive, we provide one of the most professional car services from Heathrow airport to London. You can book our Executive car Services in Heathrow, and get going in style. Our cabs are well maintained and driven by chauffeurs that will leave an impact of positivity as you are dropped at the venue.
So, call us now @ 020 8205 0901 to book your ride or visit our website for more information.

Posted by: car services from Heathrow airport to London | Nov 3, 2020 3:49:06 AM

Watch Free Pinoytambayan and pinoytv with us on pinoytvlover website in high quality result.

Posted by: Pinoylambingan | Oct 20, 2020 4:23:13 AM

Watch Free Pinoy teleserye and teleserye with us on pinoytvlover website.

Posted by: Pinoy Lambingan | Oct 20, 2020 4:04:06 AM

Thanks dear admin you have provide once again quality content.

Posted by: Watch Bigg Boss 14 | Oct 20, 2020 3:46:36 AM

Great information, Thanks for sharing!!

Posted by: Coastal Decorators | Oct 16, 2020 7:18:07 AM

Great information, Thanks for sharing!!

Posted by: Coastal Decorators | Oct 16, 2020 7:17:55 AM

Great information, Thanks for sharing!!

Posted by: Coastal Decorators | Oct 16, 2020 7:15:14 AM

You’ve written nice post, I am gonna bookmark this page, thanks for info. I actually appreciate your own position and I will be sure to come back here.

Posted by: pick and mix sweets | Oct 14, 2020 12:28:50 AM

The post is absolutely fantastic. Lots of great information. This is a great post & very useful, are you interest to Daily Hadees In Urdu

Posted by: HadayatOnline | Oct 12, 2020 5:27:27 AM

"I Really Loved this post. This is very infomative Post. Keep updated More. Do you want to Buy Ahram? Ramadan Umrah Ahram in Pakistan
with free shipping and cash on delivery"

Posted by: SharaiLibas_com | Oct 10, 2020 3:31:28 AM

Hey, That's Really Awesome Information Thanks For Sharing This. Keep It Up. Kissasian Dramas Online 

Posted by: Kissasian Dramas Online | Oct 6, 2020 7:24:33 PM

Nice sharing, Thanks for sharing this type of posts, I search many time this type of post, are you interest to Top 5 antiviruses for window

Posted by: CurrentAffairsMagazine_com | Oct 5, 2020 2:36:45 AM

Watch your favorite Pinoy Tambayan, Pinoy TV, Pinoy Teleserye Replay. Keep checking back for fresh new videos update everyday. Thanks!

Posted by: lambingan teleserye | Oct 4, 2020 6:58:39 AM

Good to see you here, good information for us, are you interest to online abaya stores with free shipping and cash on delivery

Posted by: SharaiLibas_com | Sep 24, 2020 10:06:41 AM

After I initially commented I seem to have clicked on the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now every time a comment is added I receive 4 emails with the exact same comment. There has to be an easy method you are able to remove me from that service? Kudos!

Bigg Boss 14 Voot

Posted by: Bigg Boss 14 Voot | Sep 22, 2020 5:19:11 AM

Good to see you here, good information for us, are you interest to A Natural Weight Loss Plan

Posted by: CurrentAffairsMagazine_com | Sep 17, 2020 5:38:18 AM

Nice sharing, Thanks for sharing this type of article, How many peoples like this post? Please tell me, also Good News for you, Islamic Post get ready for Daily Hadith Updates

Posted by: HadayatOnline | Sep 16, 2020 4:46:48 AM

Very Infomative Article i like this Visit This WebSite: HadayatOnline for Hadith Sharif In Urdu & Daily Hadees Updates

Posted by: HadayatOnline | Sep 16, 2020 4:44:17 AM

I hope it will be helpful for almost all peoples that are searching for this type of topic. I Think this website is best for such topic. good work and quality of articles Thanks

Posted by: saimladla | Sep 11, 2020 1:32:58 PM

Riya Sharma as Dr. Mayura character was amazing fantastic & fabulous.
Makers. Writer. Colors TV. Director. & Saurabh Tiwari is doing great job we'll done.
Sahil Uppal & Riya Sharma best joldi ❤️❤️❤️ 💙💙💙💙.
Especially. I like the character Sahil Uppal as Omkar has Rock
One of the my favourite TV show Pinjara Khubsurti Ka & best TV show.
Hat's of all the Pinjra Khubsurti Ka team for wonderful performance.
I didn't miss a single episodes.

Posted by: Pinjara Khubsurti Ka | Sep 8, 2020 4:09:08 PM

Nice post. I learn something totally new and challenging on websites I stumbleupon every day. It's always useful to read through articles from other authors and practice something from other sites.

Pinjara Khubsurti Ka

Posted by: Pinjara Khubsurti Ka | Aug 24, 2020 8:03:26 AM

Post a comment