« How do you solve a problem like Iqbal? | Main | Two small thoughts on Citizens United »

Thursday, January 21, 2010

After the Health Reform Crack Up: Govern through crime?

Former Clinton adviser Mark Penn lays out the case for a Bill Clinton post-1994 model for Obama to come back to the "center" and "swing voters" after the apparent crack up of his signature health reform initiative. Whatever the politics of swing v. base voters going into, rather than coming out of, a mid-term congressional election (which may be important) it is also worth remembering that what Clinton did in that period was to help enact some of the worst pieces of crime legislation in the history of democratic societies including a host of new federal death penalties, the Anti-terrorism and Effective Death Penalty Act of 1996, the Prison Litigation Reform Act, and many other laws that helped the states achieve unprecedented prison populations during an era when crime was already declining.

Fortunately the public is not as primed for a crime centered populist swing as it was in 1994 with the murder of Polly Klass driving the media. Still, it is hard to see where, other than in punishing despised criminals, the two parties can agree on strong sounding laws. In that spirit, and tongue only partially in cheek, look for the some of the following to take up all the extra time the Senate will have on its hands after health reform is off the table:

  • A federal death penalty for insurance executives whose decisions can be shown to have shortened the life of an insured (now that's a "death panel" baby).
  • LWOP for Bank executives who short their own client's position.
  • Lifetime Sex offender registration and notification requirements for public office holders who commit adultery while in the District of Columbia.

Cross posted at Governing through Crime

Posted by Jonathan Simon on January 21, 2010 at 12:45 PM in Criminal Law, Current Affairs, Jonathan Simon | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference After the Health Reform Crack Up: Govern through crime?:


Post a comment