« Long-Time Reader, First-Time Blogger | Main | SEIU & Election Politics »

Monday, November 03, 2008

Pelphrey v. Cobb County: The Newest Round of Legislative Prayer Battles

I've been doing a bit of academic writing about legislative prayer lately, and couldn't resist a short post on the most recent legislative prayer case -- the Eleventh Circuit's decision in Pelphrey v. Cobb County.   It is huge on both of the two major doctrinal issues -- first, whether legislative prayer can be "sectarian" in the sense of using identifiably denominational language (i.e., words like "Jesus" and "Allah"), and second, whether government can pick and choose among prayergivers on the basis of their religious affiliations.   The Eleventh Circuit said yes to #1, and no to #2.  So going forward, Cobb County can have sectarian prayer, but it has to stop having its clerk weed out Islamic, Jewish, Mormon, and Jehovah Witness prayergivers.   (No joke there: The county clerk located prospective prayergivers by going through the phone book.   Her phone book was apparently turned over in discovery, and she had crossed out a number of sections, including "Churches-Islamic," "Churches-Jehovah's Witnesses," "Churches-Jewish," and "Churches-Latter Day Saints."  Those groups just didn't get called.)

So Pelphrey means that there are now two circuit splits on legislative prayer issues.  The Fourth Circuit earlier came to the opposite conclusions on both doctrinal issues -- it held that sectarian prayers are flatly unconstitutional, and that government can indeed select prayergivers by religious affiliations.   (That latter point was made in a startling case where a Wiccan got a letter in the mail saying that she wouldn't be allowed to pray because, well, she was a Wiccan.)  End result: Both the appeal and the cross-appeal here have arguably certworthy issues to raise.  Very interesting times....

Posted by Chris Lund on November 3, 2008 at 05:33 PM in Religion | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c6a7953ef010535d62c4d970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Pelphrey v. Cobb County: The Newest Round of Legislative Prayer Battles:

Comments

My favorite part of the Pelphrey facts is that the line drawn through the "Churches--Islamic," "Churches--Jehova's Witnesses," and "Churches--Jewish" entries in the phone book was the same kind of line drawn through the "Chiropractors," "Cigar & Cigarette Accessories Dealers" and "Circuit Board Assembly Repair Persons" sections.

I've always been fascinated by legislative prayer, especially at the House and Senate level. Last fall, when researching a book that I was writing about church-state law (www.holyhullabaloos.typepad.com), I fulfilled a long-term professional goal of going to DC and actually watching the Senate prayer being given on four consecutive mornings. The Senate Chaplain, Barry Black, is incredibly charismatic and has a beautiful voice. I was surprised by how powerful the prayers were, particularly in the grand setting of the Senate. To my mind, this makes the prayer practice more consitutionally questionable than I had originally thought, but it was certainly interesting to watch.

Posted by: Jay Wexler | Nov 4, 2008 12:58:08 PM

Post a comment