« More reflections on hiring | Main | Research Canons: Employment & Labor Law »

Wednesday, September 27, 2006

State v. Fido

In 1750, in Vanvres, France, an unmarried couple was caught in flagrante delicto. Pursuant to the ecclesiastical law of the time, they were tried and convicted of fornication and sentenced to be hanged. The man, Jacques Ferron, went to the gallows, but community sentiment swelled on behalf of his partner. The townspeople swore an affidavit that they knew her to be “virtuous and well-behaved”, and the judge, moved by popular sentiment, pardoned her. Oh, and there’s one detail I left out: the female defendant was a donkey.

This story comes from one of easily the strangest, but also one of the most interesting, law books I’ve read recently: E.P. Evans’ The Criminal Prosecution and Capital Punishment of Animals. The monograph, originally published in 1906, is about just what its title suggests—the medieval and early modern practice of subjecting animals to criminal process. Evans catalogues numerous cases where the state brought criminal actions against pigs, cows, donkeys, vermin, and swarms of insects. The accused were typically jailed (in the company of human inmates), tried (complete with publicly appointed defense counsel), and if convicted, subjected to sanctions that ranged from a knock on the head to capital punishments (hanging at the gallows, burning at the stake, and even burial alive).

Evans makes no secret of his disdain for these practices, and it’s easy to read the volume as an example of the transition (of both criminal law and society’s treatment of animals) from the benighted medieval world to the humane and enlightened modern one. But for a few reasons, I think the real story is a bit more complicated.

The stories Evans relates might be taken to suggest that to the medieval mind, animals and humans alike possessed equivalent moral agency—after all, why punish in the absence of culpability? But a closer reading of the evidence suggests that this isn’t quite right. Scholastic philosophers—including Aquinas—wrestled with the conceptual issues raised by subjecting animals to penalties designed to regulate human society. Their solution relied on notions the modern mind would find familiar: an acknowledgment of animals’ limited sentience (after all, while not human neither are animals rocks or bacteria); and the need to incapacitate animals that placed humans in danger. And the notion of punishing animals is not entirely foreign in contemporary society, as anyone who has shouted “bad dog” at a miscreant pet can attest.

Nevertheless, something seems absurd and tragically unnecessary about the practice of publicly punishing animals for criminal acts (to say nothing of the practice of subjecting humans to the same treatment). If animals pose a danger to society and must be put down, fair enough, but why make a public spectacle of it? Evans locates this practice within the strikingly inhumane treatment of animals that prevailed in pre-modern Europe. There is certainly some evidence for this. The work of Robert Darnton and Mikhail Bakhtin on early modern popular culture each observe the prevalence of torturing animals as a form of entertainment during festivals. Darnton in particular notes the irony of this practice becoming particularly widespread during Enlightenment-era France.

Evans confidently asserts that animal treatment has improved since the illiberal practices that prevailed as recently as the early nineteenth century. But it’s worth pointing out that being subjected to criminal process wasn’t all bad for animals. Society’s greater sense of their agency entitled animals to legal process that occasionally resulted in clemency, such as the pardoned donkey in Ferron’s case or the French case of a sow and cow whose convictions of capital offenses were overturned on appeal. The idea that animals possess moral agency thus cuts in two directions. By contrast, the contemporary notion that animals are not persons under the law divests them entirely of any formal legal protections, save for those a local jurisdiction chooses to extent through anti-cruelty statutes. Modern state determinations that dangerous animals need to be put down are summary and unreviewable.

But things have to be better for animals nowadays, with at least a modicum of public-law protections, right? Probably, but it’s a closer call than Evans and others might assume. Many of the practices that prevailed in centuries past (publicly torturing animals as family entertainment, for example) wouldn’t wash today, thanks to both animal cruelty ordinances and public mores. But while we’ve grown squeamish about watching animals be tortured, we don’t seem to be particularly worried about the existence of the practice when it’s easily ignored. The onset of factory farming has probably enabled extreme animal suffering on a less visible but far more widespread scale than existed during the periods that Evans and others describe.

Despite this, though, I’d still guess that animals today are better off than they were in earlier eras, just as the quality of life for humans has seen massive progress since then. But while I loved reading the Evans monograph, I think there’s some danger in his assumption that the attitudes and practices it catalogs—however strange they may seem—are nothing more than absurd relics of long-gone, backward societies. These practices had thoughtful theoretical foundations based in the dominant ideas of the time and brought their own balance of social costs and benefits. And I suspect that in a few hundred years, legal historians may look at our own conceptual and practical approach to animal welfare (near-total denial of animals’ legal status, widespread toleration of extremely cruel farming techniques) with the same mixture of horror and amusement with which contemporary readers regard the practices described in Evans’ book.

Posted by Dave_Fagundes on September 27, 2006 at 12:06 AM in Criminal Law, Odd World | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference State v. Fido:


Thanks for sharing this amazing post

Posted by: Noah Backlink | Dec 13, 2019 8:51:50 PM


Posted by: Noah Backlink | Dec 4, 2019 4:32:37 PM

Quality Carpenter Port St Lucie is an excellent woodworking service provider for your construction needs.

Contact Details

Phone Number: 772-932-5878
GMB: https://goo.gl/maps/JHM5TvmVuV1zqbzPA
Website: http://portstlucie-carpenters.com/

Posted by: Lucie Carpenters | Nov 13, 2019 3:49:42 AM

Awesome!! Keep it up so I can come back for more.

Posted by: john smith | Nov 8, 2019 5:39:17 PM

Really enjoyed this page.

Posted by: Mike Mulligan | Oct 22, 2019 1:51:40 PM

I Loved The Way You Discuss The Topic Great
Work Thanks For The Share Your Informative Post.

GMB: https://goo.gl/maps/K8QTuVW9rqW5D5mn7
Visit our website @ https://www.calgaryhottubservices.com

Posted by: Hot Tub | Oct 7, 2019 2:56:02 AM

Good Post!

Would you like to visit our website: http://www.731roof.com

We are Cincinnati roofing contractors proudly serving our area since 2007. Our expertise and quality work have given us Master Elite and Select Shingle Master status with the highest quality roofing suppliers. As Cincinnati roofers, we understand that your home is more than just four walls and a roof, which is why we are also a premier siding contractor and window contractor. So the next time you are in need of roofing, siding, or windows, give us a call. Schedule your free estimate today!

Thankyou! Have a nice day!

Posted by: Rob Mantanus | Sep 23, 2019 6:17:03 AM

Love It. Great Post.
Geotagged Map: https://goo.gl/maps/QET8vZMSVAEVVe2T8

Posted by: miami2019 | Aug 26, 2019 3:15:11 AM

Great post, please keep on sharing amazing article like this!
Visit our website at http://www.miamieifs.com or Call now +1-305-422-9627!

Posted by: Miami EIFS | Aug 22, 2019 11:31:16 PM

Whittier Demolition provides the best pool demolition services to all of California. As Professionals, We Provide High-Quality Services. An analysis of what you can expect your Whittier Demolition team will do your expatiations.

Posted by: Pool Demolition | Jun 15, 2019 2:53:10 AM

Whittier Demolition provides the best pool demolition services to all of California. As Professionals, We Provide High-Quality Services. An analysis of what you can expect your Whittier Demolition team will do your expatiations.

Posted by: Pool Demolition | Jun 15, 2019 2:52:24 AM

We always want to create a family-owned business that would allow our passion for food and our love of people to come together.
TLC Catering has given us the opportunity to share what we love with you. CALL (916) 454-0852 OR MAKE AN ONLINE @ www.tlc4catering.com

Posted by: TLC Catering | Jun 10, 2019 1:36:53 AM

Looking For Medical Benifits of Coconut Oils?

Posted by: Charles Freeman | Jun 2, 2019 9:40:11 PM

Thanks for the cool article

Posted by: Lori Page | May 22, 2019 9:35:44 PM

Looking for the best restoration company Rapid Restoration is open to serve! Contact Main Office: 772-343-0002 Now! You can also go to our place at http://rapidrestorationfla.com/

We are a locally owned and operated mold removal, flood water extraction and smoke/ soot restoration services company.

Posted by: Rapid Restoration | May 16, 2019 4:44:19 AM

Looking for the best rapid restoration company? rapid restoration Cocoa beach is open to serve! 321-723-1116 Contact Now! You can also go to our place at http://rapidrestorationfla.com/

Posted by: rapidrestoration Cocoabeach | May 16, 2019 4:21:01 AM

Nice article,keep it up. visit-http://gcpublicadjusters.com [email protected]

Posted by: GoldCoast PublicAdjusters | May 7, 2019 8:40:49 AM

Looking for the best company Boardwalk is open to serve! Contact Boardwalk 54-463-6969 Now! You can also go to our place at http://www.boardwalkftl.com/

Posted by: Boardwalk123 | May 7, 2019 12:44:49 AM

Looking for the best company of Appliance Repair Services? Contact A Plus Appliance Repair Now! 561-463-8079 or Visit us @https://www.aplusappliance-repair.com/

Posted by: A Plus Appliance | May 6, 2019 6:13:54 AM

Its very impressive posts. Thank you for sharing it. Keep it up. visit/call @http://richardsaviation.com/wp/ 954-292-7608

Posted by: Richards Aviation | May 3, 2019 10:04:18 AM

thanks for sharing, visit&call @[email protected]/954-242-9319

Posted by: CSICrimeScene Intervention | May 2, 2019 8:38:55 AM

Whittier Demolition Contractors offer Emergency Building Demolition Services in Whittier. All our workers are well equipped, highly-experienced, and knowledgeable. Kindly contact us if you are looking for Demolition Services.

Posted by: Building Demolition | May 2, 2019 6:53:36 AM

I found your suggestions very reassuring and incredibly common-sense-useful! Loved this post and I’m definitely pinning it to share! Thanks for the great read and awesome tips!

Posted by: https://www.aurorachimneysweep.com/ | May 1, 2019 10:05:29 AM

It is very impressive post. Thank you very much for sharing it to us.

Posted by: Tri County Steamers | Apr 23, 2019 12:18:06 AM

Thanks for sharing pls visit&call @impressiveautobody.com/954-530-3624

Posted by: ImpressiveAuto Body | Apr 22, 2019 6:51:46 AM

I Loved The Way You Discuss The Topic Great
Work Thanks For The Share Your Informative Post.
786-602-0777 Call or Visit us @miamitile.com

Posted by: Miami Tile & Renovation | Apr 17, 2019 8:50:30 AM

I Loved The Way You Discuss The Topic Great
Work Thanks For The Share Your Informative Post.
786-602-0777 Call or Visit us @miamitile.com

Posted by: Miami Tile & Renovation | Apr 17, 2019 8:50:04 AM

I Loved The Way You Discuss The Topic Great
Work Thanks For The Share Your Informative Post.
601-340-9211 Call or Visit us @ https://Hattiesburg-contractor.com/

Posted by: Hattiesburg Contractor | Apr 17, 2019 2:42:07 AM

Monster Steamer Carpet Cleaning Service San Diego has been built by word-of-mouth referrals from the very beginning,
unlike the big corporate or franchise operations that spend millions on advertising or promotions.
That means two things for you: 1. We have lower overhead so we can provide better value
2. Your satisfaction with our process and results is not just a nice goal but an essential building block for our
entire company Most of us would rather do business locally if possible.
We get that … but we also know that quality, value and reliability are essential.
We at Monster Steamer carpet cleaning service are committed to providing the best of both worlds:
the personal attention and attention to detail you get with a local business –
with the speed and reliability of a large national company.


Posted by: MonsterSteamer CarpetCleaning | Apr 15, 2019 3:51:27 AM

Great post! We are real estate attorneys in La Crosse, WI and we totally support your sentiment.

Posted by: Real Estate Lawyer | Apr 11, 2019 2:24:15 PM

What a plot twist in the first paragraph!!

- Carlos, Dearborn Lawn Care Pros

Posted by: Carlos Kelly | Mar 13, 2019 12:19:22 AM

Very useful resource and one i shall be spending more time browsing. I am very much interested in the law section.

Posted by: Eric VanDenBerg | Feb 22, 2019 10:13:32 AM

Whoops. Such an article. click here

Posted by: click here | Jan 7, 2019 8:08:08 AM

Very interesting post. I've never heard about this practice. It seems a bit excessive to our eyes, and, as you suggest, it may have been, but one can see where these societies were coming from when one considers the high value of a mule or horse back then, as well as the financial and logistic difficulties in replacing them. With that in mind, one can see the necessity for a trial. To do otherwise would be like the government coming along and impounding your new car without just cause. A society wouldn't stand for it.

Posted by: Sam | Sep 28, 2006 10:26:26 PM

The donkey wouldn't be the only one punished if it were executed, and I'm not convinced that prosecutions of non-human participants in criminal activity "are nothing more than absurd relics of long-gone, backward societies".

Posted by: arthur | Sep 27, 2006 1:25:04 PM

Best first paragraph ever.

Posted by: keith talent | Sep 27, 2006 12:27:38 AM

Post a comment