« Suffolk Hiring Announcement | Main | Dr. Richard Pan Sued for Blocking Users on Twitter »

Tuesday, July 31, 2018

Radio discussion of NFL anthem policies (Updated)

Last week, I appeared on Gurvey's Law at KABC to discuss the NFL's national anthem policies; that discussion is in the first half-hour. I got pretty strident at points, although I am not especially strident in my position on this issue--as a matter of law, I accept that the NFL  can stop the players from kneeling (subject perhaps to CBA limitation). But one of the hosts insisted that anyone who refuses to stand for the anthem or God Bless America should leave the country, so I could not let that one go.

Update: Slate's Hang Up and Listen Podcast did a supplement (it starts around the 1:03 mark, although you may have to be a Slate-Plus member) to its prior discussion of US Soccer player Jalene Hinkle, apparently after numerous listeners wrote to ask how Hinkle differs from Colin Karpernick and other NFL players kneeling for the anthem. The hosts tried very hard to distinguish the situations, but basically landed on some version of: 1) Stop creating false equivalence between non-controversial messages against police brutality and messages of exclusion of historically disadvantaged groups; 2) teams and leagues can create their own messages, such as LGBT Pride, and compel players to go along with it. Number 1 is naked viewpoint discrimination--teams and leagues must allow player speech I agree with but not speech I disagree with. Number 2 swallows both situations--if teams can compel players to promote its preferred message, it always can do that, regardless of the message (pro-LGBT, pro-law-and-order, whatever).

Posted by Howard Wasserman on July 31, 2018 at 06:11 PM in First Amendment, Howard Wasserman, Law and Politics | Permalink

Comments

I thought these were the least strident things I've ever heard from you on a speech issue. I was hoping for (and half-expecting) emotive recitations of your favorite lines from Barnette. The co-host was dreadful and your equanimity in responding to her nonsense was very impressive.

Posted by: Asher | Jul 31, 2018 10:00:27 PM

Post a comment