« Beware of "Town of Greece" Bearing Gifts | Main | FSU Law Is Hiring, 2013 edition »

Monday, May 20, 2013

More on the Town of Greece

Following up on Paul's post, just a few quick thoughts (for now):  First, I agree entirely with Paul that his book, and Chris Lund's excellent article, are must-reads on this subject.  Since Chris is visiting at Notre Dame next year, I look forward to learning a lot from him about this case. 

Next -- and proving true, I guess, Paul's predictions about disagreements-among-friends -- I think it would be a good thing if the possibility Eugene Volokh raises - i.e., that the Court might re-examine the so-called "endorsement test" -- came to pass.  I think the criticisms directed at that test in Steven Smith's 1987 article had and have force. 

Finally, even if the justices leave the "endorsement test" in place, I hope they do not follow the Second Circuit in importing that test into the legislative-prayer context.  Yes, this context is an anomalous one and, yes, Marsh was and is something of an outlier, given that it prioritized history, tradition, and practice over the "wall of separation" idea.  For reasons I mention in this very short piece, I don't think the courts are very good at deploying all-things-considered balancing tests that purport to somehow measure the effects of religious displays and the like on the feelings of hypothetical "reasonable observers" and so they probably shouldn't try.  Better, it seems to me, to either (a) rule out legislative prayers as per se unconstitutional "establishments" or (b) police the practice for discrimination in selection and leave the issue of particular prayers' content to politics and (dare we hope?) a spirit of charity.  

Posted by Rick Garnett on May 20, 2013 at 12:51 PM in Rick Garnett | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c6a7953ef01910258918f970c

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference More on the Town of Greece:

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Post a comment